I could REALLY use some advice here for your input on our resort.
To start with - here are the "facts"
We had our resort appraised 12 years ago and it came in at $650,000. We also have a stand alone condo appraise at $300,000. Total appraised price is $950,000.
Now, for the tricky part - we are now listing it for $1,250,000 and it made a potential buyer question why we were asking $300,000 more than the numbers we posted above. Part of the issue is we also have 7 condos under management with bookings a year out in advance. Additional revenue on these condos will bring in approx. $60,000. Yes, I know they are blue sky for assets, but they are under contract all the same. Secondly, we have always upgraded with our resort - every single year since we have owned it. In 2016 we were the winners of the Green Energy award from Branson. 4 time Cert. of Excellence from TripAdvisor and have made significant enhancements to the rooms (50" LED televisions - pillow top mattresses - new drywall - etc.)
This potential has said he wants us to run another appraisal and justify the sales price. If we can get the appraiser to justify the extra he will be interested in continuing forward with negotiations. Additionally, he wants us to pay for the appraisal which we have already said is not going to happen. We know the resort will not appraise for that much as the appraiser is going to stick to the facts and maybe bring it in at $750 or $800. They cannot count the extra revenue in from our management because that can evaporate at the will of the owners but that is highly unlikely as we generate a lot of revenue for them.
The other thing that is important to note is this. Our location is a monster - literally. We are directly across from the marina and 2 miles from one of the premiere amusement parks in the nation. Even more, the entire property sits on flat land - which for around here is remarkable. The previous owners had a gas station and convenience store when we bought and we passed on that. My wife and I were financially well off already and honestly, did not want the hassle - even with more revenue.
This is not a distressed sale by any stretch of the imagination. We could literally (and would happily) keep our place for 5 more years. It has been one of the most financially rewarding and peaceful investments we could have ever made. Super low stress and high returns. Just thinking that it would be fun to buy the 2nd home on the Med and retire a little bit earlier than planned. :)
Is it reasonable to price beyond what the appraisal returns and to also insist on the buyer paying for it?
Would appreciate some insight here if possible. TIA, Mike