Now to actually answer the question you asked.
Where do I go from here? Here's how I made $85 K....now what?
I would say a quick strengths and weaknesses from what you've shown about yourself on this thread. Strengths - great craftsman and you love doing it, good eye for design, financially conservative can save money and run a project to a budget, FSBO success, possibly willing to do live in flip. Weaknesses - general flipping knowledge, financing, raising money, deal finding, delegation.
I suggest you work on those 3 items J Scott mentioned so that you can exercise your strengths and execute a project. Work on Finding Deals, Raising Money and Business Strategy. You probably have to do the last first.
Strategies that might be good for you, Fix and Flip, partner and flip, live in flip, buy a very distressed multi to live in and fix. Work as a contractor as an apprentice for a successful real estate investor. I don't know what you want to do or your goals but I'll talk about fix and flip as your choosen strategy.
Learn fix and flip fundamentals. Tons of free podcasts, Join ICOR and use the free library to do fix and flip courses, talk to me and borrow mine, buy a course, go through all the BP training and books on flipping.
Network locally, check meetup tons of events. Tell people the skills you have and your goals and what pieces of the puzzle you have, you have some capital you have construction, you have FSBO resale or you can always get a good realtor, you don't have a deal or skills to get one and you probably don't have full financing to make a cash offer with no contingencies.
Get your financing in place, are you going all cash, are you using hard money, are you going to partner with a money partner, are you going to get a fha owner occupant loan? Learn the options and pick the best one so you can be confident you can close on a deal you find.
Figure a way to get a deal. Learn marketing, you said you talked to people and they had plenty of offers. Of course they did. Only 1 out of 25 offers wholesalers make to people who allready self selected and replied to direct mail or internet marketing saying they wanted to sell select a wholesale cash offer. Did you make 25 offers that fit your conservative nature in the last 6 months of your search. Probably not. Get a realtor and work on delegating. Have them bring you opportunities, you evaluate and offer. try to find a hungry wholesaler that has a deal but doesn't have construction skills or money. Find an old vet that is tired of managing bad contractors, split a deal for doing the rehab and learn on the job. Do any of the things Travis Speer said to do.
Learn deal analysis and valuation / appraisal get access to the MLS.
Definetly a lot to get done but if you start taking action I bet you'll have another project to do what it appears you love to do and make a craftsman home with your own hands with your own great design touches.