@Nathan Emmert @Simon Campbell ... Or anyone else that reads this.
Nathan, in your example above (very well communicated by the way) you have a scenario where the property makes 8.5% CoC at about $1,900 per year.
I haven't yet purchased a buy & hold, but I've been interested for a while now. My concern with buy & holds has always been expenses down the road that will inevitably occur. For example, a pipe or roof leak, HVAC issue, etc.
Even if you're holding out a percentage every month for this scenario, it's likely not to cover the full repair cost and you'd have to eat into your profit (depending on the issue it could eat all of your profit plus future profits).
With this in mind, I've always felt that I'd be more comfortable in only purchasing multi-units / apartment buildings as buy & holds. This way I'm getting multiple door cash flows that can help offset these potential costs.
Have any of you ever run into this issue with SFRs? Is there anyone out there that only buys SFRs, or only buys multi units for B&H? Just curious to hear from those more versed than myself in this area.
And Happy New Year everyone!