Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Beth Hale

Beth Hale has started 0 posts and replied 13 times.

Post: Before you invest with Scott Carson, Inverse Assets/Investments

Beth HalePosted
  • Specialist
  • Denver, CO
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 50

Again, Erin, let me congratulate you and thank you coming forward.

I hear over and over again people say that they wished they would have known about somebody else's experience before they themselves went down that same road.

If you hadn't come forward with your story on the website, and the 18 court filings, and people with similar experiences hadn't shared, then how would others ever be warned?

If we all feared slander over warning other people, then we would enable Scott to continue this behavior. It's pretty obvious to me that after 18 court filings, all mentioning a JV agreement that sounds frightfully similar to mine, that this is a practice, and not an isolated situation.

Again, I say thank you.

Post: Note Investing

Beth HalePosted
  • Specialist
  • Denver, CO
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 50

There are lots of places, and people you can learn about notes from.

I might be careful investing or training with this person.

www.investwithscottcarson.com

Post: Before you invest with Scott Carson, Inverse Assets/Investments

Beth HalePosted
  • Specialist
  • Denver, CO
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 50

Christopher, would you be willing to share the "wise educator", as those are wise words, indeed?

Erin, you have done potential investors a HUGE favor in presenting the actual Court Filings, for those people on the fence who think this is an isolated occurrence.

18 people filing lawsuits is more than just a couple of investors getting impatient with the situation.

Thank you for sharing.

Post: Before you invest with Scott Carson, Inverse Assets/Investments

Beth HalePosted
  • Specialist
  • Denver, CO
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 50

Erin,

I laud the site!  Court filings are public record, and I respect that you want to warn others about what at least 19 people have fallen into!

As an almost victim myself, I think it's high time that this sort of information was made public.

Post: Scott Carson - NoteCamp

Beth HalePosted
  • Specialist
  • Denver, CO
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 50

Yes, I agree with Kimberly,

I seem to be alone in my opinion that maybe, just maybe, somebody ISN'T the hot shot note investor he says (and teaches) he is, if he is consistently unwilling and unable to pay his investors.


Apparently, Erin L. at least agrees with me.

www.investwithscottcarson.com

Post: Another victim of Scott Carson, We Close Notes and Inverse Assets

Beth HalePosted
  • Specialist
  • Denver, CO
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 50

My first concern would be that the "Ponzi pod cast" would give more publicity to the very machine that has caused so much financial pain to so many.

Post: Another victim of Scott Carson, We Close Notes and Inverse Assets

Beth HalePosted
  • Specialist
  • Denver, CO
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 50
My second concern would be for the privacy of the victims. I mean, obviously they would be volunteering to be interviewed, but that almost seems like forcing them to add injury to insult.  Having said that, I really appreciate you trying to educate the public about it.
 

Post: DO NOT INVEST with SCOTT CARSON (We Close Notes) or Inverse Asset

Beth HalePosted
  • Specialist
  • Denver, CO
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 50
Originally posted by @Adam Adams:

I've seen a lot of comments in regards to risky investments, bad management, incompetence and such. I think you need to go back to Gerry's and Al's comments. Once you give money to Scott, the communication stops. No updates on the investment. No distributions. Nothing. Even legal action doesn't get anything out of him once he has your money. The only time he'll get back with you is when he thinks you are going to hurt his business, as in the case of this post. Most of the posts in the past have been taken down because he pays off his investor. Testor v Carson was the first one I saw. Testor put up a website that a few people saw. Scott saw it, paid him off and it was down shortly after. Other posts have been in his basecamp forum. Very short-lived posts because the OP gets paid off.  Anyone notice that he's suddenly got a ton of CFDs for sale. He he's raising money from Peter to pay off Paul to get this post down. The guy takes your money and runs away with it to Disney Euro. Same goes for the guy I invested with that is his buddy that used to be an attorney. Every month I'm on the phone with someone out there that calls me wanting to know what I know about these two. Every time I go to a conference, more people are wanting to know more about what I know. Why me? Heck if I know. Maybe because I did a ton of videos for him. Whatever the reason, I do get a lot of calls. And since this post started, I've got 7 people calling and writing to me wanting to know what I know. And it's not just Scott that's a crook from that group. 

And while this comment might hurt a lot of people including myself, everyone needs to have some suspicion with all of Scott's associates and former associates. I know I do. These are not incompetent investment managers. These are crooks who con you into showing you the ropes of the business using their positions as mentors and "successful" note players. Then they want you to buy their crappy notes or JV with them on their crappy deals. Success is just around the corner if you just let them show you how, and pay them. @Michele Orgel named a few, but unfortunately, she didn't name them all. I'd name them, but my wife will kick my *** if I do. 

Adam,  

Thanks for getting the subject of this thread back to where it started.  I was concerned when it trailed off into "You can always lose money with your investments ...."

This post is about "I invested money with him, and then I didn't get any updates about what was happening. The year went by and then I requested my money back as per the JV agreement. I got some of it back (or not in some cases). Then he went dark on me."

Again, I think it's pretty captain obvious that we can all lose money on our investments.  But one doesn't expect the one who is MANAGING the money to: 

a)  not return our calls or texts

b)  not return our emails

c) fail to provide you with "accounting" on all of the assets with a basecamp account, as the JV agreement said

d)  not make quarterly payments from the assets that reperform

e)  not appear to be "working out" the assets at all

f)  fail to return the principle and 12% interest after the year is up and the assets haven't sold

g) JV with ANOTHER party on the same asset(s) he JV'd with you on (which happened to me).

This is not just "losing money" while investing.  The is gross mishandling of funds on the part of "guru" taking your money.  

Now, I don't expect anybody to be squeaky clean on every point, but when he doesn't return calls and emails on top of it all, what's an investor to think.

Post: DO NOT INVEST with SCOTT CARSON (We Close Notes) or Inverse Asset

Beth HalePosted
  • Specialist
  • Denver, CO
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 50
Originally posted by @Martin Saenz:
Originally posted by @Alpesh Parmar:
Originally posted by @Martin Saenz:
Originally posted by @Alpesh Parmar:

@Gerry Cohen thanks Gerry and others for sharing your experiences. When I was starting out, I was going to attend his mastermind but then I attended Eddie Speed's and I wasn't impressed either. All of these guys want to make money from courses, workshops, coaching, JV investors and investors trying to buy assets from them. It's like they have nothing to lose - it's only win-win for them.

I'm pretty much staying out of the conversation as I have never had a dealing with Scott and can't speak from experience.  My heart goes out to those affected by a bad encounter I must say.  I would only mention that in fairness to Note School, Eddie Speed's program may not be for everyone, however he and his team have done a tremendous service to the note industry over the years.  They lobby on Capital Hill, etc on behalf of all us note investors for one.  I want to give credit were credit is due and know that Eddie and his team do care about maintaining standards in the space whether or not their system is a fit.  

 

You have been in note industry so you must be right @ his contributions. I haven't done business with Eddie so can't say anything but the one full-day workshop I attended was up-selling of 3-day workshop and note school conference. I was immediately put off by the up-selling.

 Appreciate you, Alpesh.  I took a 3 day Note School workshop when I first started in 2013 and I understand there is up selling.  Moving further into their program was not a fit for me at the time however it gave me my launching pad in the industry.  They run a big operation and need to feed that system accordingly.  With that said, my impression of Eddie (and what I hear from many others in the industry) is that he truly cares about upholding standards within the space, and I believe that strongly with his team too.  I just don't want him lumped into a ethics thread involving someone different (as they are different people running different operations).  That's just my two cents, sir.

I agree with you regarding Eddie Speed.  I am proud to say that I got my training in the business from being a Note School student, and he is part of the Seller Finance Coalition lobbying on capital hill on behalf of seller finance and the investors like us who make this part of our business model.

I would also say that Eddie Speed and the folks at Note School keep their material fresh, and appropriate for today's market conditions, which have seen changes in the last few years.

I would also agree with you for saying that Eddie Speed tries to maintain integrity in his dealings.  I feel the same way.

I think we should be slow to paint everybody teaching notes with the same brush.  I suspect Scott Carson has more in common with Bernie Madoff than he does with Eddie Speed.  I'm just sayin'.....

Post: JV investors with Scott Carson?

Beth HalePosted
  • Specialist
  • Denver, CO
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 50

If I may, people are STILL ponying up money to Scott Carson.  I was at a note convention in June, and my friends in the industry (who also lost money with Scott) said they knew somebody who just invested with him the prior month.

Of course, I can't be sure, but I think the Scott Carson machine is still successfully collecting money.  How else could he be financing his European vacation and his Hawaiian vacation - and that's just this year?

Also, as somebody who has read all of the initial complaints from the lawsuits listed in the other post, the first one goes back to 2012!  And it reads pretty much the same as the current ones.  

My point, that I was hoping to make much more succinctly, that while it's lamentable so many people fell into this trap, it's really fortunate that the news is finally coming out. Who knows how many people's self directed IRA's we are protecting!