Thought I would give everyone an update on our marketing efforts thus far. After taking the advice given here, we decided to go big on our marketing efforts. Instead of mailing 395 people like we were, we went out and bought an absentee owner Listsource list of just over 5,000 people.
So far we have sent out 8,395 pieces of mail (one more round of 1,679 to go on our second mailing) and our response rate is at .24% (OUCH!). That works out to 20 phone calls from those 8k+ pieces of mail or $263 a phone call.
For those who want to know, we are using the Zip Letters from Yellowletters.com as our mailer. We've also purchased postcards for our 3rd round of mailer based upon Michael Quarles' advice.
My question is, why are our response rates so awful? They've actually increased from .18% to .36% from round 1 to round 2 (apparently all that advice about repeat mailings is true, although those numbers should be higher). Is it the area we invest in (East Bay, California). Does our messaging suck? Is the market completely over-saturated with RE investors? If you were in my shoes, what would you do differently? We are committed to sending out a postcard towards the end of next month, but we don't know how much longer we can sustain this with such pitiful results - the time to pull the cord on this experiment is getting close.
Any advice, counseling, strategies, words of wisdom or ideas would be a great help to us.