@Candace Berry
Great job with the renovation!
It's a great location and a unique one. The allure of being inside the beltline is appealing to many. The neighborhood seems to have a bit of everything - large luxury homes, college rentals, and residential multifamily. VERY close to NC State campus. Corner of Brooks and Everett, which are both popular cross thru streets.
I noticed that the listing square footage > tax record square footage by about 150%. Which is accurate?
IMO, pricing will trump any other factor when selling a home. If the MLS sqft is correct, you are priced close to the top of the market for a .5 mile radius (not a bad thing these days!). If the tax sqft is correct, the home may be overpriced...
@Dawn Brenengen is correct about listening to the feedback you've received. With 160 days on market, you should have plenty to go on. Many realtors will leave 1-2 sentences after taking their clients to see the home. It may be worth a phone call to them to see if you can get a better feel for things.
Kudos to you for doing some research before dropping the price on a +$800K house.
Good luck!