Quote from @Michael Smythe:
@Ashley Ernst we disagree with @Mike Paolucci
While he could be right and this may be "normal", the opposite is too risky.
You haven't shared enough details, but what are the chances the seller is a flipper or turnkey provider who threw the first applicant they got into the property just to make a sale happen? You get stuck with a tenant you'll probably have to evict at some point, then repair any damages they've caused and then find a new tenant. What will all that cost?
Where is the property?
What Class is the property?
What is the tenant's credit score, income & job stability, rent payment history with previous landlords, etc?
How long has the seller owned this property?
How long has the property been a rental?
What repairs have been recently made according to your inspector?
Any recent building/electrical/mechanical/plumbing permits pulled at city?
Worse case, how many months of rent will the seller discount on the price to make you comfortable moving forward with the purchase?
Michael - This was super helpful and, quite frankly, your comment that "what are the chances the seller is a flipper who threw the first applicant they got into the property just to make a sale happen" is what my concern is. Seller owned the property 4 months and did some remodel before putting tenant in the property and immediately selling it. Property is rented for $100 over the avg for the C+ area, which already made me suspicious, but when running the numbers, it still cash flows even if I assume avg rent for the property. Property was a rental prior to this for several years (I confirmed with prop mgmt company that used to service the property prior to the Seller buying it. This morning I finally received the report run on the tenant prior signing the lease. Tenant has poor credit, no eviction history, and two historical collections on record. To me this is a ticking time bomb...