Hello have you calculated these properties based on "hard" data (ie numbers)? What is cashflow, CoC?
Compare that to the more "soft" data. Type of tenant base, potential for rent and property value appreciation, ...
Compare that to what you are looking for. Location, how much work you are willing to put into a property, etc.
Both properties have pros and cons. Your goals, skills, etc will help dictate decision. Right it out in a comparison chart based on metrics that are important for investment and for you personally.
For my first house hack, I had similar choices. Ideal location / needed work / high appreciation potential vs not ideal location / needed no work / ok appreciation. For my goals, skill set, and knowing that I would live there... I chose the former and I'm happy.
Do the homework to compare options objectively. If its still not super clear, sometimes it comes down to gut feeling. Good luck with your decision!