Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Anthony Rondinelli

Anthony Rondinelli has started 1 posts and replied 9 times.

Quote from @Connor Goggans:

Hi, Shane,

I work with Milwaukee County Housing Services as a Landlord Engagement Coordinator.  We have a mixed bag of federally subsidized, as well as non-federally subsidized rent assistance programs, many which abide by rent assistance Housing Quality Standards requirements.

For Housing Quality Standards, screens are not actually required...if they are present, though, they must be in good condition so as to not posed a cutting hazard or other health and safety risk


Hope that helps

Hi Connor, is there a website you could direct me to that tells me requirement/criteria for rent assistance for both landlords and tenants in Milwaukee? Do you know the rents the city pays for 2 and 3 bedrooms?
Quote from @Jay Hurst:
Quote from @Anthony Rondinelli:
Quote from @Jay Hurst:
Quote from @Anthony Rondinelli:
Quote from @Jared Rine:

My post broke the quick math down of your hypothetical situation. It shouldn't be affecting your DTI negatively unless something's wrong. Since 75% of the proposed income more than offsets the PITI of the loan, it's a wash. I don't know where you are, but you might want to get another analysis. If you're in CA or AZ, feel free to reach out. And to answer your question, yes, DTI issues are usually why investors start using DSCR loans. Which I also have experience doing.

No, it didnt. Adding even money to a 35% DTI could theoretically bring the DTI almost to 50%
Say you start with $3000 debt/$10,000 income(30%DTI)...then add a property that debts a million dollars and grosses a million....you now have debt of $1,003,000 and income of $1,010,000..whats that debt to income ratio?


That is not how it works. If you have a PITI that will be 4000 dollars, but the property will bring in 5000. You will take 75% of that 5000 which is 3750. So, that would add 250 dollars to your debt to income ratio. In your example above now your debt goes from 3000 a month to 3250 a month. so, your DTI HAS gone up but only to 32.5% from 30%.

Look at this form from Fannie. You would be looking at the bottom section step 2b: https://content.enactmi.com/documents/calculators/Form1038.C...

You dont add the total new debt, and total new gross income(understood its after 75%, I was presenting my numbers after accounting for that)??...so again in my initial example: Starting with $3000 in debt/$10000 in income(30%DTI)...adding a property that PITIs $4000 and gross incomes(after 75%) $6000...you are telling me that you add the difference only to income, or debt if its not cash flowing? Not the totals? In this scenario my DTI would be $3000debt/$12000 income?(25%DTI) And not $7000 debt/$16,000 income?(43.75%)

I feel like some of you are not understanding what I am actually asking...very possible im not asking properly...
It is how I and the actual form that the underwriter would use lays it out. Again, the actual source. It is really simple, and you are vastly overcomplicating it.  Please look at the @b part of the form I linked and let it do the math for you. 
Ok I looked at the form, that helped considerably. Seems the simple answer, is that yes, if you have a positive qualifying income you are good.  If its negative it is added to your debt, but only the difference. I only wanted to know if this spread is used (positive or negative) or the total intital numbers...Thanks for the help, good to see that form!



Quote from @Jay Hurst:
Quote from @Anthony Rondinelli:
Quote from @Jared Rine:

My post broke the quick math down of your hypothetical situation. It shouldn't be affecting your DTI negatively unless something's wrong. Since 75% of the proposed income more than offsets the PITI of the loan, it's a wash. I don't know where you are, but you might want to get another analysis. If you're in CA or AZ, feel free to reach out. And to answer your question, yes, DTI issues are usually why investors start using DSCR loans. Which I also have experience doing.

No, it didnt. Adding even money to a 35% DTI could theoretically bring the DTI almost to 50%
Say you start with $3000 debt/$10,000 income(30%DTI)...then add a property that debts a million dollars and grosses a million....you now have debt of $1,003,000 and income of $1,010,000..whats that debt to income ratio?


That is not how it works. If you have a PITI that will be 4000 dollars, but the property will bring in 5000. You will take 75% of that 5000 which is 3750. So, that would add 250 dollars to your debt to income ratio. In your example above now your debt goes from 3000 a month to 3250 a month. so, your DTI HAS gone up but only to 32.5% from 30%.

Look at this form from Fannie. You would be looking at the bottom section step 2b: https://content.enactmi.com/documents/calculators/Form1038.C...

You dont add the total new debt, and total new gross income(understood its after 75%, I was presenting my numbers after accounting for that)??...so again in my initial example: Starting with $3000 in debt/$10000 in income(30%DTI)...adding a property that PITIs $4000 and gross incomes(after 75%) $6000...you are telling me that you add the difference only to income, or debt if its not cash flowing? Not the totals? In this scenario my DTI would be $3000debt/$12000 income?(25%DTI) And not $7000 debt/$16,000 income?(43.75%)

I feel like some of you are not understanding what I am actually asking...very possible im not asking properly...
Quote from @Jared Rine:

My post broke the quick math down of your hypothetical situation. It shouldn't be affecting your DTI negatively unless something's wrong. Since 75% of the proposed income more than offsets the PITI of the loan, it's a wash. I don't know where you are, but you might want to get another analysis. If you're in CA or AZ, feel free to reach out. And to answer your question, yes, DTI issues are usually why investors start using DSCR loans. Which I also have experience doing.

No, it didnt. Adding even money to a 35% DTI could theoretically bring the DTI almost to 50%
Say you start with $3000 debt/$10,000 income(30%DTI)...then add a property that debts a million dollars and grosses a million....you now have debt of $1,003,000 and income of $1,010,000..whats that debt to income ratio?

Quote from @Jared Rine:

@Anthony Rondinelli..lenders have different nuances that have to be taken into account. It's not a one-size fits all. Some lenders are going to have overlays or not understand how to actually calculate rental income properly (full disclosure - I've closed loans that were turned down because of a banker or loan broker not understanding how to calculate income). There are lenders who even if you haven't filed your taxes can use the income to offset your PITI, which should barely raise your DTI, especially in the type of example that you mentioned. While you can't use any overage to help your income, you can offset (if the rents are enough) for a 1:1 and basically have no add to the income. In your example. $6,500 x .75 = $4,200 which covers $4,000 PITI. While you cannot use the $200 overage for income, it becomes a wash for the debt taken on, and should add nothing to your DTI. PM if need more info.

Why would it be a "wash" if it affects your overall total numbers negatively? 
Quote from @Tyler Warrick:
Quote from @Greg Scott:

You are talking to the wrong mortgage people.  It is very common for the typical bank mortgage person to make this mistake.  I've heard it first-hand.

A mortgage person that understands income producing properties applies 75% of the rent towards your income. If you are buying cashflowing properties, your DTI should improve with every property.

Greg brings up a good point, but keep in mind you can only offset the subject property income by using 75% of the rent UNTIL you file it on your tax returns. Only at that point can an underwriter recognize it as an income producing property.


Again, this is understood. What I am getting at, is if it is worrisome, or avoidable, as even a good deal(see scenario above) will raise DTI

Quote from @Andrew Zamboroski:
Quote from @Anthony Rondinelli:

Hi,

If I want to maintain a healthy DTI for a primary residence conventional loan in a couple years, what should I be aware of, or what strategies must I employ? My current W-2 and rental income(4 duplexes in my name) have me at about 35%DTI, I am about to add another multi-fam property and it would bump my DTI to 46% even though it cash flows $2000...Do people simply start buying in LLCs(DSCR) at this point for this reason?

Any advice appreciated.

You will want to ensure you are claiming income on your return. While losses help offset taxes, not being able to count that income towards the mortgage can hurt you when purchasing something new.

 I do, and will count the new income.

Quote from @Greg Scott:

You are talking to the wrong mortgage people.  It is very common for the typical bank mortgage person to make this mistake.  I've heard it first-hand.

A mortgage person that understands income producing properties applies 75% of the rent towards your income. If you are buying cashflowing properties, your DTI should improve with every property.


 This not true, mathematically.

take this hypothetical: Current DTI-35%- $3750 Debts/$11,000 gross income

add a property that PITI is $4000, Gross income is $6500($2500 positive cash flow), now your DTI has grown to ~44%...$7750 debts/$17500 gross income

Hi,

If I want to maintain a healthy DTI for a primary residence conventional loan in a couple years, what should I be aware of, or what strategies must I employ? My current W-2 and rental income(4 duplexes in my name) have me at about 35%DTI, I am about to add another multi-fam property and it would bump my DTI to 46% even though it cash flows $2000...Do people simply start buying in LLCs(DSCR) at this point for this reason?

Any advice appreciated.