@Benjamin Voorhis This is a very common challenge to most investors. Conventional loans have very specific rules concerning cash out loans on investment properties. Conventional loans are the loans governed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac (if you recognize those names). Conventional loans are the loans that give us the most favorable terms; 30 year fixed rates, no prepayment penalties, the lowest rates, etc. There are two very important rules that apply to cash out investment property loans when using conventional money (portfolio is different and we will address that later):
1. If you purchased the property with cash (or a HELOC) then you can get your initial investment back (purchase price) + closing costs OR 75% of the After Repair Value...whichever is the lower amount.
2. if you purchased the property with a small loan, and then used cash to do the repairs, then you are limited only refinancing the loan balance in the first 6 months of ownership.
However, for portfolio lending these rules don't apply. Well, what I mean is that portfolio lending is up the the bank itself so the bank may or may not have these types of rules (I've actually seen portfolio loans that don't allow cash out at all). But portfolio loans will carry a higher rate, have a shorter payback period, be an adjustable rate, etc.
The method that most investors use to refinance is to wrap the repairs into the loan so you don't tie up any more money than you need to. Hope this helps.
I will private message you. Thanks!