Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Andrew Lawlor

Andrew Lawlor has started 3 posts and replied 15 times.

Post: LA Property with lots of Equity

Andrew LawlorPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 15
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Dan H.:
Quote from @Andrew Lawlor:
Quote from @Anna Brown:

I purchased my Los Angeles (Compton) 4-bedroom home in 2013 for 240K; according to Redfin, it is now worth 686K. 2 years ago the entire house was completely renovated (Insurance claim) due to a burst pipe that caused extensive damage while vacant. I'm not sure what I want to do or what my options are. I've been thinking I would like to fix the outside landscaping/fence/Kitchen cabinetry and roof so I that I can get the max rent or just sell and buy in the midwest, 1031 exchange (not sure if I qualify). I mainly would like to expand my portfolio using the equity but am hesitant to refi because my current rate is 3.3%. Even Airbnb would be an option but I'm starting to feel like I need a partner who knows what they are doing to guide me. HELP!!

Anna, you're sitting on gold if this property is large enough to accomodate an ADU. For a 2 bed, 1 ba ADU, you'd likely generate around $2500-$3k rent/mo, which may cost around $175k-$225k+ (variable depending on the quality of the build). You'd be in the range of $1750-$2k/mo in HELOC costs on a 20-year with a 9% rate (within reason for a primary residence w/good credit). If you do opt for a HELOC, I'd consider starting with LA Federal Credit Union and getting a few quotes from other local lenders. LAFCU was the most responsive, hassle-free lender among the many I reached out to for a prior HELOC. Feel free to reach out with other questions and good luck whichever direction you choose to go!


Besides all the issues with ADU additions such as value far less than ADU addition, primary becoming rent controlled, cost outlay long before any income, detracting from primary Even if it is just yard and privacy, the amount of effort required, I question how you think this works cash flow rise.

I do my underwriting always using the worst of any ranges.  Rent $2.5k. P&i $2k.  Prop tax 1.1% of $225k is $187/month.  Insurance varies significantly if attached versus detached so going conservative we will use more expensive detached at $50/montn.  Vacancy 5% is $125. Pm at 8% all inclusive is $200.   Maint/cap ex $300. Misc $50.  $2500 - $2000 - $187 - 50 - 125 - 200 - 300 - $50 = -$412/month.  Now compare with 50% rule $2500 (rent) - 2000 (P&i) - 1250 (50% rule)= -$750/month.  

a lot of work to likely start with a negative equity position and negative cash flow.


Best wishes

Agree that this wouldn't pencil with the 20-year HELOC at 9%, but the idea would be to refinance at completion with a conventional mortgage (30-year at 7%) which would effectively reduce the monthly payment to apprx $1500/month (again this depends on total cost of build). And while agree with putting out conservative estimates, a quick cursory search suggests that a new rental in this area would likely generate closer to $3k/mo.

Post: LA Property with lots of Equity

Andrew LawlorPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 15
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Anna Brown:

I purchased my Los Angeles (Compton) 4-bedroom home in 2013 for 240K; according to Redfin, it is now worth 686K. 2 years ago the entire house was completely renovated (Insurance claim) due to a burst pipe that caused extensive damage while vacant. I'm not sure what I want to do or what my options are. I've been thinking I would like to fix the outside landscaping/fence/Kitchen cabinetry and roof so I that I can get the max rent or just sell and buy in the midwest, 1031 exchange (not sure if I qualify). I mainly would like to expand my portfolio using the equity but am hesitant to refi because my current rate is 3.3%. Even Airbnb would be an option but I'm starting to feel like I need a partner who knows what they are doing to guide me. HELP!!

Anna, you're sitting on gold if this property is large enough to accomodate an ADU. For a 2 bed, 1 ba ADU, you'd likely generate around $2500-$3k rent/mo, which may cost around $175k-$225k+ (variable depending on the quality of the build). You'd be in the range of $1750-$2k/mo in HELOC costs on a 20-year with a 9% rate (within reason for a primary residence w/good credit). If you do opt for a HELOC, I'd consider starting with LA Federal Credit Union and getting a few quotes from other local lenders. LAFCU was the most responsive, hassle-free lender among the many I reached out to for a prior HELOC. Feel free to reach out with other questions and good luck whichever direction you choose to go!

Post: STR to Custom Home Builds

Andrew LawlorPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 15
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Brady Morgan:

A few suggestions from an investor turned builder.

Learn the code for your area forward and backward. Just about everywhere in the US uses some version of IRC for its base code and then makes some changes to that as they feel necessary for their locality. I would suggest starting with reading the IRC book all the way through multiple times. Then add any other codes required where you want to build and study those as well. Do not rely on your subcontractors to know/perform the code correctly for your area. This is one of the biggest things that people dont think about when they decide to skip hiring a GC.

Become a familiar face with your local planning and zoning board/committee. This is who will approve or deny your plans when you apply for a permit. Go to some meetings ahead of applying, talk to the members of the board and ask questions if you have any. A lot of problems that arise during permitting and planning can be avoided by being proactive.

Build relationships with sub contractors. This is a tough one for new builders. The good subs in your area will likely have plenty of work already and may not even return phone calls. This is one area where it helps tremendously to have per-existing relationships with people in the industry such as family or friends. The best way to get through the door with subs is a recommendation/connection from someone they respect. Also talk to the local building inspectors and find out who they recommend and who they constantly have problems with. I am also the building inspector for my small town and I certainly know who the good subs are and arent. On the topic of building inspectors, make them your best friend. They can make or save a lot of headaches for you. Make sure you understand exactly what they want to see and when, all through the build process. Nothing will piss off the inspector faster than missing an inspection.

My last piece of advice, in an effort to not make this a book length post, deals with the money. You need to know what things cost. I have spreadsheets filled with material lists for every phase of the build that includes pricing for materials as well as labor, and sources that I use for them. Underwriting a new construction is like a flip on steroids in terms of volume, however you will find that you can get a much more accurate budget in the end because unlike a flip, there are very few unknowns going into it. The trick is just not forgetting something.

Hope this helps! I am a big proponent of self GCing new construction investments, as long as it is done correctly. Not an easy thing, but saving 20% or more on the cost of a new home seems well worth the time and effort if you ask me. I am currently working on starting a youtube channel that will teach what I have learned in becoming a builder, along with following some of my builds start to finish.

Thanks for the detailed response! Would you mind sharing the link to your YouTube channel (if you’ve already started it)? I’d love to hear more about your building experience, knowledge, etc. 

Post: STR to Custom Home Builds

Andrew LawlorPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 15
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Jacob Sherman:

you can utilize no income no doc construction loans . fund 50% of the land 100% of construction upto 65% ARV . What is the scenario looking like ?


 I'm not currently at the phase of transitioning into a home builder, more trying to learn the steps of how to better set myself up for success. I have construction loan on the current house I'm building and used similar strategy (land was purchased outright and used to cover majority of the down payment). I'm just not the builder on this one since the lender wouldn't finance for owner/builder. 

Post: STR to Custom Home Builds

Andrew LawlorPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 15
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Peter Mckernan:
Quote from @Andrew Lawlor:

I've been actively investing in short-term rental properties for the past three years, managing one live property and another that will go live in two months. I'm now considering expanding my real estate ventures into building custom homes, but I know this is an entirely different beast between the required capital, learning curve, time committment, etc. I'm not completely foreign to the construction process as I grew up around a family that was involved in home building, but due to living in another state I can't really lean on them for the direct, hands-on guidance. 

For background, I'm partnered with an architect and interior designer, but I'd have to find most of the subs as I don't have any formal connections (at least in the area I'd like to build). I have about $100k in capital reserves and can leverage the 2 properties for additional capital, as needed. My goal would be to start within 1-2 years and get some more experience with the construction process, project management, financing/budgeting, etc. What would be the best ways to familiarize myself with construction process, while still maintaining my W-2 job? 

I know this is a big leap, but any advice, criticism, or resources are greatly appreciated. Thank you! 


 I would get in touch with a local builder, and see about getting a mentorship on down days and days you have off.. PTO days you can tackle this stuff with the contractor as the mentor and do.. Or even a contractor that does large additions and then move towards ground-up stuff. There is a lot of stuff to cover, so try to make as much time for it as you can while working your W2. 


Great idea. I'll reach out and see if any would be willing to offer some sort of mentorship. 

Post: STR to Custom Home Builds

Andrew LawlorPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 15
  • Votes 7

Thanks, Bryant! That'd be great. I'll shoot you a message. 

Post: STR to Custom Home Builds

Andrew LawlorPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 15
  • Votes 7

I've been actively investing in short-term rental properties for the past three years, managing one live property and another that will go live in two months. I'm now considering expanding my real estate ventures into building custom homes, but I know this is an entirely different beast between the required capital, learning curve, time committment, etc. I'm not completely foreign to the construction process as I grew up around a family that was involved in home building, but due to living in another state I can't really lean on them for the direct, hands-on guidance. 

For background, I'm partnered with an architect and interior designer, but I'd have to find most of the subs as I don't have any formal connections (at least in the area I'd like to build). I have about $100k in capital reserves and can leverage the 2 properties for additional capital, as needed. My goal would be to start within 1-2 years and get some more experience with the construction process, project management, financing/budgeting, etc. What would be the best ways to familiarize myself with construction process, while still maintaining my W-2 job? 

I know this is a big leap, but any advice, criticism, or resources are greatly appreciated. Thank you! 

Post: Thoughts on Manufactured Homes?

Andrew LawlorPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 15
  • Votes 7

I initially had a similar plan in 2021 but shifted gears swiftly upon discovering that they depreciate faster than stick-built homes, their lead time isn’t much faster or cheaper than a ground up build, and home owners insurance can be tricky due to certain criteria you need to meet (i.e. must be on a foundation). On the upside, some prefab companies offer financing which is much easier to obtain than a new construction loan. If you end pursuing the prefab, just make sure to do your due diligence. Hope this helps! 

Post: Killington and Stowe Land

Andrew LawlorPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 15
  • Votes 7

Thanks for your feedback, Kathleen! The Stowe market is the preferred choice but the inventory seems even more scarce than Killington. I would love to connect to discuss the idea of seeking out owners that may be interested in sub-dividing. I’ll send you a message so we can connect. Thanks! 

Post: Killington and Stowe Land

Andrew LawlorPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 15
  • Votes 7

Thanks, Michael! These are all great tips. I routinely check Craigslist, but didn't think to check Facebook Marketplace or joining any local STR groups. I'll certainly include these to expand my reach.