Hey @Allie Bloyd, for a pre screen that's about a $100K when in normal condition. Rural area in Oldham, Trimble, Henry, -$10K. If it's a desirable part of Louisville or Oldham, start adding maybe $15-20k. In your example house the limit is that 1K SQFT, that's a pretty small house by most standards and they usually don't build 1K sqft houses in nicer neighborhoods next to 2-3K sqft houses.
For HUD and foreclosure (and short sales for that matter) you need a patient agent. The work will be higher than any other house they help you buy and it's going to take a lot longer to close and get paid. Make sure your agent is up for that kind of a job or ask if they know someone who is.
Agent comps can be good but they can really screw up to. With that ball park in mind if the list price looks reasonableish I'd do a drive by to see the neighborhood and condition of the house in person. Only by going there do you really get a feel for if there's a bad area or if the neighbors are taking care of their property. It also lets you know the quality of the comps (were they pulled from the right area or from some different neighborhood that's got a very different feel and value?) .
@Jay Leisten is right, but in my experience, most agents treat new investors like a speculative stock. Alright to keep around, but don't put more money into it until it shows promise. As a new investor you have to do a lot of lead generation yourself and the only way to get quicker turn around is good prescreening so your agent spends less time pulling details on junk that doesn't come close to the criteria. If you fall in with a good agent that has a steady stream of investment grade properties that they can clue you into quickly it's awesome, but mostly as a rookie, we're stuck doing our own leads and making that effective means good prescreening.