@Brenton Kasselder
We agonized over pricing. It's so hard right now, because inventory has been nonexistent, so there are very few comps.
On the other hand, get this -- the same day we listed ours, the guy TWO HOUSES DOWN listed his house at $145,000. I almost fainted when I saw that. He has no yard, and reading between the lines, there are no updates/upgrades in his house, but still.
Houses of the same age nearby that are similarly sized and in similar neighborhoods have been flying off the shelves at $165,000ish with multiple offers. Nothing makes sense, though -- we toured a similar house with NO updates (gross, old carpet, dirty paint, old appliances), and it lasted only a week at $169,000.
In our subdivision, in the last 90 days, there have been three sales. A 4/2/2 at $169K (updated), a 3/2/0 at $179K (mostly updated; layout exactly like ours except they converted the garage into living space), and a 3/2/2 at $141K (no updates). Current 3- and 4-bed listings in our subdivision are listed at $150K (few updates), $145K (mentioned above) and $278K (he's dreaming).
So we'll see how the house does at $180K. I really hope we haven't misjudged the situation. After a spring of no listings, inventory has abruptly increased around us -- mostly similar homes with no upgrades/updates -- so I hope that doesn't end up hurting us.