Hi @Tim Mieney-
This is quite the DD post! I wish I would've seen this prior to my REI Turnkey journey!
With that being said, I have invested with 2 turnkey providers, R2R (6 properties) and Norada (1). The Norada property is a new build in the Ocala area so I don't have a lot of background with them. They've been communicating regularly and have been easy to work with thusfar.
R2R - I've had the most experience with and the relationship I've developed with @Zach Lemaster is probably why I have 6 properties from their company. As with any turnkey company, you are paying a premium for your property but on the flip side you avoid all of the "risk" and effort on the front end. For me this made sense in my situation and I knew it going in. I have 3 rehab properties from R2R and 2 have outperformed their proforma and easily cash-flowing $250-300 per month. The other, has been more of a struggle largely due to the tenants put in place and the PM company. I reached out to Zach early on to get his assistance and he (as mentioned earlier) is very responsive. We weathered the storm, got new tenants and aa new PM company in place and were able to increase the rent as well. He was also able to recoup some of the damages done by the tenants as well. I will say that, even after you've purchased the property, they are always there to support you along the way. For completeness, I have 3 new builds with them in the Cape Coral area - 1 is nearly complete and the other 2 are waiting permitting.
I've had a very positive experience with R2R and would recommend them. I do think it worthwhile, to have a discussion with them to ensure they meet what you are looking for.
Just my 2 cents! This was a very helpful breakdown!