Should I charge tenants for the brand new or the used model?

[Guka Kagu]

My tenants just moved out. They damaged the cooktop due to negligence and abuse. I need to replace the whole unit. The company doesn’t make the same model anymore and the similar model is around $2800.

My second option is to buy a used one online for $2100. Let’s say I go with the second option. Can I still ask for $2800 since they got a brand new cooktop when they moved in.

Thank you!