Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here

Join Over 3 Million Real Estate Investors

Create a free BiggerPockets account to comment, participate, and connect with over 3 million real estate investors.
Use your real name
By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.
The community here is like my own little personal real estate army that I can depend upon to help me through ANY problems I come across.
Real Estate Deal Analysis & Advice
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

Updated almost 13 years ago, 01/14/2012

User Stats

60
Posts
7
Votes
Sharon Rolel
  • Birmingham, AL
7
Votes |
60
Posts

Duplex in Bushwick, NYC

Sharon Rolel
  • Birmingham, AL
Posted

Hello everyone,

Would appreciate if anyone could analyze this.

I'm from Canada, and looking at this 2 family in Bushwick:

2000 SF lot
3180 SF built

Currently rented long term to section 8's, at 2,500$ for the larger apt, and 1,440$ for the smaller one. There is a basement that is maybe convertible to a third apt.

Taxes 170$
Hydro 30$
Mgmt 394$
Insurance 125$

No rehabbing needed, and assuming that I won't need to put anything into maintenance, as I was assured this is generally the case in NYC. (surely not losing 50% of gross rent like in other areas)

This boils down to:

3,046$ pre-tax monthly
36,552$ annually

the house is for sale at 372,000 including ALL expenses, including legal, title, first year insurance, broker fees, and forming an LLC.

So the cap rate is 9.82. I will try to finance this but getting a mortgage as a Canadian won't be easy. I can put up to 100% down, however, so I'll work something out.

The property is located in almost the southernmost point of Bushwick, though near the subways and bus stops. (5 mins walk)

This was offered to me by a friend who I trust. An experienced RE broker and former agent.

Comps are 450,000$, 505,300$, 550,000$ suggested by him and verified by me.

Thanks!

User Stats

1,550
Posts
291
Votes
Uwe S.
  • Property Manager
  • Dublin, OH
291
Votes |
1,550
Posts
Uwe S.
  • Property Manager
  • Dublin, OH
Replied

Hello Sharon,

with nearly $370k in cash you can buy a 20 - 30 unit in OH, NY or PA with an higher CAP rate than this in NYC. Thats only my first thinking.

Forthe duplex, you should calculate anytime with 50% expenses (maintenance etc.), when I calculate with only 45% you will net $26,000 per year so a CAP rate of only 7%.

Do the math, even with the comps if you want to buy and hold long time I wouldn´t invest in this house, only if you have to much money in your bank account its worth to buy.

-Uwe

User Stats

60
Posts
7
Votes
Sharon Rolel
  • Birmingham, AL
7
Votes |
60
Posts
Sharon Rolel
  • Birmingham, AL
Replied

Uwe,

I appreciate the reply.

The number I provided after expenses, which amount to around 20-25% of the rent. I was assured that in NYC renters are more responsible for maintenance, and that the house is quite new so it won't need that much maintenance.

Other properties I own I do use 50%.

As a Canadian who doesn't frequent the states that much I would love to invest in the best properties I can find but often I am at the mercy of the management company I find, and this one is managed by one I have experience with, so that is also a consideration.

BiggerPockets logo
Join Our Private Community for Passive Investors
|
BiggerPockets
Get first-hand insights and real sponsor reviews from other investors

User Stats

1,316
Posts
569
Votes
Nathan Emmert
  • Investor
  • San Ramon, CA
569
Votes |
1,316
Posts
Nathan Emmert
  • Investor
  • San Ramon, CA
Replied

You believe someone on Section 8 rent is going to maintain their own house? You do understand what Section 8 is right? You do understand the rules of maintaining Section 8 status for rentals right?

User Stats

60
Posts
7
Votes
Sharon Rolel
  • Birmingham, AL
7
Votes |
60
Posts
Sharon Rolel
  • Birmingham, AL
Replied

I assume every case is different, section 8 is not a tag... I will make sure to get the management reports about the expenses for the property in previous years. I will judge the expenses according to that. Anything else you see that may need further inspection?

User Stats

838
Posts
295
Votes
Chris Masons
  • Investor
  • Union, NJ
295
Votes |
838
Posts
Chris Masons
  • Investor
  • Union, NJ
Replied

Nathan is absolutely right. Be VERY careful about what you expect and what you will get with a section 8 tenant. ALso you should verify section 8 is paying 2,500 for an apt. How big is this aapt? How many bedrooms? Here in NJ a section 8 voucher for 3 bedroom is around 1600.00 I understand NY is probably higher but just verify all this. You should not count on your section 8 tenant to maintain the building.

Have you considered investing in NJ? Very NY commutable and there are some great buys right now. I am not too familar with the NY market but can tell you, you can do much better elsewhere.

Is there a reason you are looking at this perticular property? Do you own others nearby?

regards,
chris

User Stats

22,059
Posts
14,124
Votes
Jon Holdman
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Mercer Island, WA
14,124
Votes |
22,059
Posts
Jon Holdman
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Mercer Island, WA
ModeratorReplied

If I'm reading that right you're paying $370K for $4000 in rent. Just from those numbers its not a good cash flow deal. Expenses will NOT be 25% of rents. You will have maintenance. You will have vacancies, even if just between tenants. I've seen no evidence the 50% rule of thumb doesn't apply to NYC or anywhere else and have seen evidence that it does apply everywhere.

User Stats

60
Posts
7
Votes
Sharon Rolel
  • Birmingham, AL
7
Votes |
60
Posts
Sharon Rolel
  • Birmingham, AL
Replied

Chris,

It is a 5 bedroom apt.

I considered many states and cities, as an out of of state (and country) investor I judge properties case by case. I have other properties, including shares in 400 unit complexes, and I am generally aware of the calculations to establish a property's cash flow potential, including 2% 50%. That's what I normally use.

This is a property that I was offered by a friend like I said, and he told me (I trust him and he is a partner in a very big RE brokerage) that 80% of the rent is what I can expect to pocket from the rent.

Thanks

User Stats

242
Posts
61
Votes
Andrew Jones
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
61
Votes |
242
Posts
Andrew Jones
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
Replied

If your goal is to buy and hold for the cash flow then 370k for 4k is simply not a good deal.