Over-analyzing and Information Overload

[Robert K. Morillo]

I've been doing research on executing flip or "wholesale" deals since the middle of February and I finally started taking steps towards finding my first nontraditional deal. I've got a cash buyer's list,  door hangers, bandit signs, business cards and a website. I designed all of my marketing materials and built the website myself, so I haven't even spent over $275.00 to get everything together. However, since I've got access to plenty of distressed property lists (not on the mls), I feel a little overwhelmed with the amount information I've taken in just the last couple of weeks. I feel as if I'm trying to do too much too fast and expecting the end result before analyzing the best leads to secure my first deal. 

Am I overthinking everything or should I just continue doing what I'm doing?