New Jersey deal opinions greatly appreciated

[Kyle Pelech]

So I am at the point of really wanting to find my first property to purchase. I would say I am addicted to trying to find deals at this point. Here's a quick thing I put together and would really like to have some opinions, please take a look and give me any and all opinions you have. I like to think I know what I am doing, but please put me in my place if these numbers are ridiculous or anything I state is impossible, all honesty please. 

2 Bedroom 1 Bathroom 800sqft home 

In a nice neighborhood, good town, and access to NYC via train station in town

This house is for sale by owner or $199k 

Let's say I get the house for $175k, 3% down payment which is $5,250 + 3,000 closing costs and whatever else = $8,250

Monthly mortgage payment, tax and insurance is now at $1,162 

The house seems to be in great condition, with a new porch in the backyard 

The houses surrounding are in the high $200k - $400k

I believe I could get $1700 a month for rent if not a bit more, considering many of my friends who have 1 bedrooms pay $1250 a month for rent. 

I would not include any utilities since it is a single family home and after research I see that many of you include utilities only when you are dealing with multifamily properties. 

So now I am at $1,700 - $1162 = $538 a month = $6,456 a year

If this is possible year after year with my investment of just $8,250 I would be very pleased

Here is the link to the home I am looking at

 http://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/39287580_zpid...