Newbie comparing 3 properties: which would you pick?

Newbie comparing 3 properties: which would you pick?

New York City, NY · Member since 2013 · 14 posts · 1 vote

Hello all,

Newbie here, been reading the forums/articles for a while, looking for some guidance. I am trying to buy my first property as an owner occupant. Considering a buy and hold strategy for a multifamily property.

I'm hoping to get your opinions on 1) how would you evaluate the 3 properties I've listed below, 2) which property, if any, would you choose among them and why, and 3) if I have failed to provide enough information (which is likely), what suggestions might you have for filling in the missing pieces?

The following properties would be financed and intended to be rented to Section 8 tenants, as they represent the primary rental population in the area.

Property 1:

2-Family

Price: $140k

Needs no work

FHA Financing 3.5% down

Gross monthly income from 1 unit: $1,100

Property 2:

3-Family

Price: $125k

Being renovated; ~75% complete

Seller financing available

Gross monthly income from 2 units: $2,200

Property 3:

4-Family

Price: $160k

Requires full renovation, potentially $60k-100k

FHA 203k financing

Gross monthly income from 3 units: $3,600

Again, please help me understand:

1) how would you evaluate the 3 properties I've listed below

2) which property, if any, would you choose among them and why, and

3) if I have failed to provide enough information (which is likely), what suggestions might you have for filling in the missing pieces?

Thank you in advance!

1Reply
27 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2011 · 12 posts · 1 vote
    13y

    Personally, I'd go with property #2. It offers seller financing which will help your credit; it's a 3-family which will generate income thereby building your equity and credit faster; and it's almost move-in ready.

    On property #3 you'll have to upgrade it and this is in addition to the list price.

  • Wholesaler · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2013 · 76 posts · 18 votes
    13y

    @George B. If you could provide the ARV of these properties, along with the respective monthly fees associated with holding each property then we'd be getting closer to which looks like a more favorable rental.

  • St. Petersburg, FL · Member since 2012 · 173 posts · 44 votes
    13y

    I agree with Will H. Property #2 looks like your best bet. There is a lot of information missing...RE Taxes, Property Insurance, etc., etc.,

    Are these properties all in New York? Those prices seem cheap for what I have heard from New York.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.