3 Questions about BRRRR

3 Questions about BRRRR

Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles · Member since 2020 · 9 posts · 0 votes
I have a couple of questions about aspects of the BRRRR process. Apologies in advance if these are obvious, I'm still trying to fully understand it.

1. When you first buy, can conventional financing be used with the same lender that you eventually will refinance with? Or do you need to buy without financing in order for this all to work?
2. Does the refinance part require a new down payment?
3. Once you refinance, your loan balance will drastically increase. And your cash flow will decrease. I understand that the point is to pull your money out of the deal and move on to the next, but doesn't this put you that much further from owning the property free and clear?
0Reply
52 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Agent · Garden City, NY · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
6y

@Jack Norris

The point of BRRRR is to lower your risks by purchasing at a bigger discount due to the distressed nature of the property. In general...

1. That means you won't be able to use a conventional loan. Will have to be cash, hard-money loan, or private loan.

2. Cash-out is usually 65% to 75% of after repair value (ARV). So, you're leaving equity in the property, which means no downpayment. But there will be closing costs.

3. You generally aren't looking to be free-and-clear. That means your money is tied up in the asset instead of using it for more purchases or repairs to existing properties.

To do the proper analysis, you have to consider the ARV cash flow once the property is repaired and rented out to make sure it will have positive cash flow after rents, mortgage, and reserves.

See this reply in the discussion

14 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Agent · Garden City, NY · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Jack Norris

    The point of BRRRR is to lower your risks by purchasing at a bigger discount due to the distressed nature of the property. In general...

    1. That means you won't be able to use a conventional loan. Will have to be cash, hard-money loan, or private loan.

    2. Cash-out is usually 65% to 75% of after repair value (ARV). So, you're leaving equity in the property, which means no downpayment. But there will be closing costs.

    3. You generally aren't looking to be free-and-clear. That means your money is tied up in the asset instead of using it for more purchases or repairs to existing properties.

    To do the proper analysis, you have to consider the ARV cash flow once the property is repaired and rented out to make sure it will have positive cash flow after rents, mortgage, and reserves.

  • Investor · Tucson, AZ · Member since 2017 · 394 posts · 178 votes
    6y

    @Jack Norris on your last point. The point of BRRRR is not to hold anything free and clear, but to have an asset that cash flows and pays the mortgage note every month. When you refinance, the goal is to pull as much money as you can out of the property so you can use this money to buy another one- that is the repeat part of the BRRRR. It's called the velocity of money. It allows you to build your wealth faster (your wealth is directly tied to the equity you have in the properties and the more you have the more equity have). As discussed by Cristopher, if you pay the loan off and own it free and clear then you will use up all your capital to buy the next one. I would recommend reading the BRRRR book. It will give you a much better understanding of the BRRRR process and how it can be used as a wealth building tool.

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Christopher Phillips:

    @Jack Norris

    The point of BRRRR is to lower your risks by purchasing at a bigger discount due to the distressed nature of the property. In general...

    1. That means you won't be able to use a conventional loan. Will have to be cash, hard-money loan, or private loan.

    2. Cash-out is usually 65% to 75% of after repair value (ARV). So, you're leaving equity in the property, which means no downpayment. But there will be closing costs.

    3. You generally aren't looking to be free-and-clear. That means your money is tied up in the asset instead of using it for more purchases or repairs to existing properties.

    To do the proper analysis, you have to consider the ARV cash flow once the property is repaired and rented out to make sure it will have positive cash flow after rents, mortgage, and reserves.

    Hi Christopher,

    I am relatively new to the BRRRR process too. Are you able to explain why you cannot use conventional financing with the BRRRR method?

    If you did 20% down on a 100K property and then did a 10K rehab and then property is now appraised for $150k. Let's say the holding/closing costs is 10K total.

    The entire cost is 20K + 10K + 10K = 40K

    Can't I do a cash out refi from the ARV 150K? Let's say I can pull out 70% which would be 105K. 105K - 80K in loans = 25K. Does that mean I can pull out 25K with my refinance?

    I understand I still have the 40K I still did not take out so technically, I am still having 15K of equity in the property after the refi.

    But my question is that if I did a refinance with my example above, would I be able to pull out 25K if I wanted to?


    Sorry, I am still trying to understand this process as well.

  • Real Estate Agent · Garden City, NY · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Jimmy Lieu

    Hi Jimmy.

    Conventional and FHA financing have condition of property appraisal specifications.

    So, a house without working plumbing, without working heat, or a leaking roof, won't pass appraisal standards. In those cases, you have to use a rehab loan product or go for hard or private money or cash.

    Many rehab products will depend on if you plan to occupy the property or not ( like living in a unit in a 2-4 family home and renting the rest of the units). If you don't plan to occupy it, then you'll have to do cash, private, or hard money or a rehab product that doesn't require occupancy. It really depends on the situation.

    Adding $10k to a property doesn't add substantial value. Maybe 20-40% return on your money depending on the value add. If you have a leaky roof, people can't get traditional financing and most people will discount the value on the home more than the actual cost of the repair.

    The power of BRRRR is that you're buying a distressed property at a substantial discount.

    With that last point in mind, if you see a house for $100k with substantial issues that can only be purchased with cash or a rehab loan, that allows you to negotiate a deeper discount.

    Let's assuming they take $80k for all cash and a quick close. Then you make the necessary repairs and cosmetic enhancements for $25k. Now you're $105k all in (plus closing costs) and a potential ARV of $150k. So, after renting it out and when you go to the bank and get 75% ARV cash out, 75% of $150k would be $112.5k. Depending on the closing costs (they can be different for each state/county/town) you can now go out and buy another distressed property.

    many investors want to buy a property with no headaches. You can't get a property like that without paying near retail. That means no discount.

    So, you have to pick your comfort level for repairs and perform all the calculations to see if the property is worth the investment.

  • Cincinnati, OH · Member since 2020 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    @Jack Norris

    As mentioned, a lot of times the nature of what you are buying makes it challenging to use conventional loans, but not impossible. This will primarily be dictated by the condition of the property you are buying. This also depends on what you mean by "conventional". If you mean a conforming loan that will be securitized by Fannie or Freddie or FHA, than the condition will dictate. If conventional financing is more to mean loans from a bank, versus hard money or private, then a lot of banks have lending products that can be used.

    No new down payment, UNLESS you don't appraise and still choose to take out the new loan.  In this instance, you would need to put more money down just to rebalance the new loan and take out the old. 

    Yes, debt balance goes up, loan payments will likely rise too (although not always depending on rate and amortization of old loan). When considering a BRRRR, you need to run numbers based on the assumed new loan terms and monthly payment. The goal is not to take out cash but go cash flow negative. The goal is to take out cash and still be cash flow positive on the property.


    @Jimmy Lieu, to add to Christopher's response, your math is correct.  But as Christopher mentions, your math being correct and application of that math does not mean you will find that deal in reality, which is where Christopher is coming from.  In reality, at least in my market, a house that is worth $150k and only "needs" $10k in work, will sell for $150k. But, there are deals out there, you just have to work really hard, network, make friends with the postal worker, send out mailers, etc to find them.  You can get deals that might sell for $150k and you can get them for $100k. This is the whole business of wholesalers.  BUT, again in reality, to get those deals, you likely need to have cash to buy.  Typically, when you can find those types of deals, the seller wants quick money, not a 45 day closing period so you can secure a loan.  They want 10 days cash in hand.

  • Rental Property Investor · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2020 · 540 posts · 285 votes
    6y

    @Jack Norris

    1. Yes you can structure it that way upfront, or check the market once you’re rehab is appraised and see who has the best offer.

    2. No your initial down payment & sweat equity in increasing the ARV functions as your down payment.

    3. I see where the paint point is there, but you're using the equity in Home 1 to finance home 2 without having to use your own cash out of pocket. You don't want to withdraw all the equity (which the bank won't let you do anyway) and the house should still cash flow enough to cover some $ for you plus cover PITI and cap ex (but if you improved it substantially hopefully you won't have much CapEx for 5-8 years).

  • Whitney HuttenPro Member
    Investor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Jack Norris Everyone here has answered your questions very well.  I'd love to redirect you to your goals now.  Is your goal to own properties all in cash and have a slow build?  Don't discount this path if it is the one you really want to be on... there is no right or wrong.

    Or is your goal to own several properties with as little of your own cash as possible into them, and allow the tenant to pay that debt off for you? The latter is where real wealth is created. BRRRR is merely a strategy to accelerate your growth and "slingshot" the equity growth without waiting on natural appreciation to do it for you. Then there are the intangibles that come with providing clean, affordable housing, and raising the standards of a neighborhood.

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles · Member since 2020 · 9 posts · 0 votes
    6y

    @Whitney Hutten

    My goal is to own several properties with tenants paying down the debt; how to best utilize the cash I have is what I'm trying to figure out. Whether i split it up for 4-5 down payments for traditional buy and holds or use BRRRR is where I'm at right now.

    For someone brand new to this, the initial buy using cash + hard money in the BRRRR route seems daunting, as well as overseeing such a large rehab project. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Garden City, NY · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Jack Norris

    That makes sense.

    Buying distressed properties can be challenging when it comes to unknown repair items.

    The other option is to buy properties that have tenants already in them or are ready to rent out. But, you won't be able to cash out and use your money again until you build enough equity. But that can take a long time depending on where you're investing at and how much maintenance and capital improvements need attention.

  • Investor · Malakoff, TX · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    IF the house will meet the conventional loan requirements you can use a conventional loan. Apart from that, you could akso finance with a commercial loan, and then refinance that with the same lender. There may be a seasoning period before you can refinance.

    No new downpayment on the refi. You'll be taking money OUT.

    You need to make sure the property cash flows after the refi.

  • Rental Property Investor · Dayton, OH · Member since 2019 · 293 posts · 440 votes
    6y

    @Jack Norris your question is not diffrent than many new investors and always hard to determine at first.

    It really depends on how much cash you have and where you plan to invest! Let me give you a great easy example......this is less risky. I use the brrrrr in most of what I do and long before it was a fad lol. But here’s a path I take new investors down in my area that don’t want rehab and want less risk.

    If you had 100k cash to invest in my area, we can buy cash flowing 4 units 80-100k all day long. I have several lenders that will lend 80% of purchase price to new investors on these. These properties easily cash flow 1200-1300 monthly. So with your 100k, we could scoop up 4 of the properties easy and you would be cash flowing 4K minimum monthly. The after collecting rent for 1.5 months, we would buy your 5th same scenario and now your cash flow is 5-5500 monthly! Not bad right? Very doable in certain markets.

    These markets where this is possible is also harder to pull off a great brrrr on these buildings and you have to go to larger buildings to see the rewards in refinance that others see in other areas of the country by buying distressed.

    My point, figure out your tolerance level, make relationships with lenders(I have several I can share), hook up with a great investment minded realtor and get rolling! Best of luck to you

  • Whitney HuttenPro Member
    Investor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Jack Norris If you find the rehab / financing pieces daunting, then just start with a rent-ready property as your first deal.  Take a gliding path and figure some of the basic puzzle pieces out first.  Your first deal will give you such great insight on what all goes into the deal.  Then perhaps you are ready to take the next step (like construction) from there.  So many investors hae done just that here (you can check out my story on #340).  Most importantly, get started!

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2019 · 199 posts · 42 votes
    6y

    @Todd Pultz dope! Where is your market. I have $100k to invest!

  • Rental Property Investor · Dayton, OH · Member since 2019 · 293 posts · 440 votes
    6y

    @Simon Obas Dayton, OH is a great market for the scenario I shared. That’s where I am at. We have a little over 100 doors here and I self manage them. Also a realtor which helps to keep some cost down and get some return back on some of the deals. Let me know how I can help you

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.