Same price - small house, attached, mint, or large house TLC?

[Michael M.]

I found two 3/3 two families.  Same neighborhood, same price.  What's worth more?  Space/ unattached, or newer boiler/ in great shape?

House 1:

- 3/3

- 2 King sized rooms, one tiny room

- decent shape

- not renovated since 1930

- needs new boiler/ removal of asbestos

- separate rooms

- massive living room

- lots of light

- unattached

- 1000 sq feet+ apartment

House 2

- 3/3

- 2 queen sized rooms, one small room

- recently renovated/ in amazing shape

- newer boiler

- attached

- 900 sq feet each apartment