Not exactly DIY but siding choices

[Todd Michaels]

We are going to hire a contractor to replace the wore vinyl siding and gutters on our 3 story 2 flat and detached garage.  We have gotten down to either vinyl siding or cement fiber.  First quote came back at $18k for vinyl and $32k for Hardie Board.  I know that Hardie board does look better and is very durable but it will require to be repainted eventually and this is quite a bit higher cost.

We currently live in one of the units and rent the other out and plan to live there for the next 5 years or so, then move to a different house and keep the 2-flat strictly as a rental; I expect us to keep the property for a good 20+ years. The price difference is pretty high but I figured I would see if any BP people would think hardie board is the way to go. 

[Account Closed]

@Todd Michaels, you are welcome.

I like your thinking. It is smart to take away and make all the necessary improvements, this will insure longevity with your property. No sense in putting whip cream on dog sh!t.

If you haven't make sure to take the time to vet your subcontractors. 

Get their referrals and call them. Ask if they we punctual, did they stay on schedule, how did they communicate, were they tidy, did they stay on budget.

Check their license for issues with the contractors board.

If they have local jobs take the time to look at their work.

These few items even though time consuming can help make your life easier.