RENOVATING - Over Renovating?

[Jake Quick]

Hello All,

I currently have 9 long term rental units and am working on a single family renovation which I intend to use as a STR. The house is a 1,050 sq ft 2br 1 bath cottage, the bathroom currently has a walk in shower. I am debating on whether I should keep the nice walk in shower or replace with a bath/shower, with keeping the re-sale in mind if I ever decide to. The tile has to be redone regardless. Thoughts?

Also, looking for any good resources regarding renovating should and should nots. I struggle on the design side of things. I feel like I tend to over renovate, I dont want to spend money on things that dont matter. I am sure there is a BiggerPockets podcast on this, if anyone can point me in the right direction would be much appreciated.

CHEERS!