Subject To Loan Modification

Subject To Loan Modification

Rental Property Investor · Newport Beach, CA · Member since 2009 · 32 posts · 2 votes

Does anyone have experience with subject to loan modification?

In this market there are many properties many properties that have negative equity. Even if people qualify for loan modification may be still inclined to walk away. With the Obama plan guidelines a loan modification can yield:

-reduce the principle balance of the first mortgage up to 33%
-have the monthly payment reduced to 31% of the borrowers income
-"waterfall" payments with a floor of 2% increasing annually to ~5% over a period of 30 years (like a neg am because it will add to the principle balance)

I ran into a situation last week where the person owed 550k and the FMV was around 300k. With a loan mod it would be possible to reduce the payment over the first year to around $850 per month. Most importantly the market rent is $2200 per month.

Also, I'm not sure what type of balance reduction or interest rate reduction could be acheived, which leaves the situation very ambiguous.

This means that if I took over the property subject to the loan being modified, the cash flow would be over $1000 per month.

My real question is would this be legal? My intuition says that there has to be something for the homeowner other than just the loan being modified i.e. a clearer exit strategy. It obviously would be a bad situation in 5 years if the loan is on their credit and the principle balance has increased again.

Any ideas or suggestions?

Gabe

0Reply
45 views

4 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Investor · dc, Washington D.C. · Member since 2008 · 392 posts · 89 votes
    17y

    Although I haven't completed one of these type of transactions, I'm working on a similar transaction (list price=310K, ARV=222K, 1st mortgage=180K, and 2nd mortgage=88K). I also intend to do this as a wrap, and I was inspired by a few ideas in some posts and chats I had with Nick J and a post and some videos by Jason H. (You can search BP for the related posts for more insight.)

    Basically, I presented my seller 3 different options yesterday: 1) short the second (Nick inspired) and I'll buy on a wrap; 2) modify the second to add a movement clause (uncommon outside of commercial--aka floating mortgage), have the seller to transfer that second lien to another property, and I'll buy the target property on a wrap; and 3) Jason's "'They Pay You' Subject To".

    Another way to do this--that I didn't suggest to the seller--is: offer to take over the payments and retail it with a lease-option to a buyer with a few dings--but no evictions, foreclosures, or bankruptcies--on his/her credit. There are other ways to handle this too, but I suspect I gave you enough ideas to get your juices to boil. :D

  • Real Estate Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2009 · 180 posts · 8 votes
    16y

    hakchinoy whats the jason pay you to sub to method

  • Lender · Chicago, IL · Member since 2010 · 84 posts · 23 votes
    16y

    FYI: I got a close look at a friend's documents who modified his mortgage according to the program: "That, as of the Modification Effective Date, a buyer or transferee of the Property will not be permitted, under any circumstance, to assume the loan. This agreement may not, under any circumstances, be assigned to, or assumed by, a buyer of the property."

  • Rental Property Investor · Mercer Island, WA · Member since 2008 · 22k+ posts · 14k+ votes
    16y

    That's effectively just a variation on the due-on-sale clause. You're always going to be violating that clause on any sort of subject to deal. Could well be, though, that a lender would be more aggressive about calling the loan due if the property changed hands after a modification.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.