NJ Insurance Company Recommendations

[Brett Baginski]

I have my first property under contract and set to close on 10/23.  My lender wants me to start getting the homeowner's insurance policy ready, so I was wondering what companies people in the NJ forum were using, or if you had an agent that you could recommend?  

The property is in Ocean County, 4 bed, 2.5 bath, 1872 sq ft and I have received the following quotes...
NJM- $831
Geico- $1,495
Farmers- did not like their customer service, but waiting to hear back about a quote
Allstate- waiting to hear back
State Farm- waiting to hear back

Thanks!