Complex disability situation - unsure of feasibility of investing

Complex disability situation - unsure of feasibility of investing

Dayton, OH · Member since 2023 · 3 posts · 3 votes

Firstly want to thank this community and forum, I've found myself being directed back to it a number of times as I've been digging around the internet for information.  I realize my situation is a complex one, and I'll try to be as thorough as possible. 

I was recently awarded SSDI, and with that about $19k in backpay.  I know that's not a lot, all things considered, but it's very likely the largest lump sum of money I'm ever going to get.  My SSDI is my only income, and my disability prevents me from working to supplement it.  I live with family so my monthly expenses are minimal and leave me with about $500 a month that I comfortably could put aside for a potential investment (and/or mortgage payment).  I would like to invest it, but my options are extremely limited.  Medicaid is need based and takes most financial assets into consideration when it determines whether you qualify.  (I would be able to collect a net cash flow of aprx. $5k from a rental without getting kicked out of Medicaid.  In two years I'll qualify for Medicare and this whole thing will be moot.)

I can't invest in things like CDs, IRAs, ETFs/Mutual funds, or any type of savings account.  Real estate is one of the few things that I can invest in that won't knock me out of qualifying for Medicaid when I have to renew next year.  So, unfortunately, if I wanted to invest this money, I'd need to do it before October '24.  If I had unlimited time to figure out what to do with it, I wouldn't be in such a pickle.  

I don't have any wealthy investor friends or family I can approach for cash.  I don't own my own home that I can put up as collateral.  So far as I can tell, pretty much all traditional mortgages, as well as down payment assistance programs and low income grants, would both disqualify me based on the debt/income that a mortgage would put me at, and necessitate my occupying any purchased real estate as my primary residence.  This would defeat the purpose of my purchase in the first place.  

DSCR loans are going to need a minimum loan amount of $100k and a down payment of 20-30%. So the minimum I'd need for a down payment is around $25-40k on a $130k house. Even if I pushed my monthly savings up to $600 a month, it would still take me 10 months to save up the $6k to hit the very bottom of that threshold. And even then, it's highly unlikely that I would secure a mortgage and close on a house before my next income review.

I live in Dayton, OH and roughly an hour from both Cincinnati and Columbus.  I could get a very nice little income property for $130k in that bubble of cities.  If I had time.  

I'm running out of ideas for how to twist this to make it work, but I doubt I've been 100% exhaustive in my research.  If anyone has any insights or suggestions, I would be extremely grateful.  Or would it simply be better to put the idea of investing out of mind, and just go on a nice vacation lol.

Thank you all so much for your time.

3Reply
80 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Consultant · Cleveland · Member since 2020 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
3y
Quote from @Elizabeth Kinde:

Firstly want to thank this community and forum, I've found myself being directed back to it a number of times as I've been digging around the internet for information.  I realize my situation is a complex one, and I'll try to be as thorough as possible. 

I was recently awarded SSDI, and with that about $19k in backpay.  I know that's not a lot, all things considered, but it's very likely the largest lump sum of money I'm ever going to get.  My SSDI is my only income, and my disability prevents me from working to supplement it.  I live with family so my monthly expenses are minimal and leave me with about $500 a month that I comfortably could put aside for a potential investment (and/or mortgage payment).  I would like to invest it, but my options are extremely limited.  Medicaid is need based and takes most financial assets into consideration when it determines whether you qualify.  (I would be able to collect a net cash flow of aprx. $5k from a rental without getting kicked out of Medicaid.  In two years I'll qualify for Medicare and this whole thing will be moot.)

I can't invest in things like CDs, IRAs, ETFs/Mutual funds, or any type of savings account.  Real estate is one of the few things that I can invest in that won't knock me out of qualifying for Medicaid when I have to renew next year.  So, unfortunately, if I wanted to invest this money, I'd need to do it before October '24.  If I had unlimited time to figure out what to do with it, I wouldn't be in such a pickle.  

I don't have any wealthy investor friends or family I can approach for cash.  I don't own my own home that I can put up as collateral.  So far as I can tell, pretty much all traditional mortgages, as well as down payment assistance programs and low income grants, would both disqualify me based on the debt/income that a mortgage would put me at, and necessitate my occupying any purchased real estate as my primary residence.  This would defeat the purpose of my purchase in the first place.  

DSCR loans are going to need a minimum loan amount of $100k and a down payment of 20-30%. So the minimum I'd need for a down payment is around $25-40k on a $130k house. Even if I pushed my monthly savings up to $600 a month, it would still take me 10 months to save up the $6k to hit the very bottom of that threshold. And even then, it's highly unlikely that I would secure a mortgage and close on a house before my next income review.

I live in Dayton, OH and roughly an hour from both Cincinnati and Columbus.  I could get a very nice little income property for $130k in that bubble of cities.  If I had time.  

I'm running out of ideas for how to twist this to make it work, but I doubt I've been 100% exhaustive in my research.  If anyone has any insights or suggestions, I would be extremely grateful.  Or would it simply be better to put the idea of investing out of mind, and just go on a nice vacation lol.

Thank you all so much for your time.

Ok so a LOOOONG story, is there a question? You do not have any money, or it seems credit, what are you asking us. If you do not have money or credit, you are not buying anything. Sorry to be blunt, I always am so do not be offended. This post just does not make sense to me
See this reply in the discussion

13 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Consultant · Cleveland · Member since 2020 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3y
    Quote from @Elizabeth Kinde:

    Firstly want to thank this community and forum, I've found myself being directed back to it a number of times as I've been digging around the internet for information.  I realize my situation is a complex one, and I'll try to be as thorough as possible. 

    I was recently awarded SSDI, and with that about $19k in backpay.  I know that's not a lot, all things considered, but it's very likely the largest lump sum of money I'm ever going to get.  My SSDI is my only income, and my disability prevents me from working to supplement it.  I live with family so my monthly expenses are minimal and leave me with about $500 a month that I comfortably could put aside for a potential investment (and/or mortgage payment).  I would like to invest it, but my options are extremely limited.  Medicaid is need based and takes most financial assets into consideration when it determines whether you qualify.  (I would be able to collect a net cash flow of aprx. $5k from a rental without getting kicked out of Medicaid.  In two years I'll qualify for Medicare and this whole thing will be moot.)

    I can't invest in things like CDs, IRAs, ETFs/Mutual funds, or any type of savings account.  Real estate is one of the few things that I can invest in that won't knock me out of qualifying for Medicaid when I have to renew next year.  So, unfortunately, if I wanted to invest this money, I'd need to do it before October '24.  If I had unlimited time to figure out what to do with it, I wouldn't be in such a pickle.  

    I don't have any wealthy investor friends or family I can approach for cash.  I don't own my own home that I can put up as collateral.  So far as I can tell, pretty much all traditional mortgages, as well as down payment assistance programs and low income grants, would both disqualify me based on the debt/income that a mortgage would put me at, and necessitate my occupying any purchased real estate as my primary residence.  This would defeat the purpose of my purchase in the first place.  

    DSCR loans are going to need a minimum loan amount of $100k and a down payment of 20-30%. So the minimum I'd need for a down payment is around $25-40k on a $130k house. Even if I pushed my monthly savings up to $600 a month, it would still take me 10 months to save up the $6k to hit the very bottom of that threshold. And even then, it's highly unlikely that I would secure a mortgage and close on a house before my next income review.

    I live in Dayton, OH and roughly an hour from both Cincinnati and Columbus.  I could get a very nice little income property for $130k in that bubble of cities.  If I had time.  

    I'm running out of ideas for how to twist this to make it work, but I doubt I've been 100% exhaustive in my research.  If anyone has any insights or suggestions, I would be extremely grateful.  Or would it simply be better to put the idea of investing out of mind, and just go on a nice vacation lol.

    Thank you all so much for your time.

    Ok so a LOOOONG story, is there a question? You do not have any money, or it seems credit, what are you asking us. If you do not have money or credit, you are not buying anything. Sorry to be blunt, I always am so do not be offended. This post just does not make sense to me
  • Dayton, OH · Member since 2023 · 3 posts · 3 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Bob S.:
    Ok so a LOOOONG story, is there a question? You do not have any money, or it seems credit, what are you asking us. If you do not have money or credit, you are not buying anything. Sorry to be blunt, I always am so do not be offended. This post just does not make sense to me

     My question is: are there any resources or strategies that this community knows of which I have not already looked into.  Or, as I said in my final paragraph, should I put thoughts of investing out of mind and just blow the money that I have on something frivolous?

  • Sarah KensingerPro Member
    Real Estate Consultant · OH · Member since 2023 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    3y

    The only way I can see something working out, is if you learn all things creative financing....Pace Morby would be the guy to check out and learn all you can from. Also, with the amount of money you have, I would suggest looking into long-term rentals over short-term rentals.

  • Real Estate Consultant · Cleveland · Member since 2020 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3y
    Quote from @Elizabeth Kinde:
    Quote from @Bob S.:
    Ok so a LOOOONG story, is there a question? You do not have any money, or it seems credit, what are you asking us. If you do not have money or credit, you are not buying anything. Sorry to be blunt, I always am so do not be offended. This post just does not make sense to me

     My question is: are there any resources or strategies that this community knows of which I have not already looked into.  Or, as I said in my final paragraph, should I put thoughts of investing out of mind and just blow the money that I have on something frivolous?


     You cant buy anything, so find deals and flip the contract to those doing deals, There are many in your " backyard

    Good luck 

  • Nicholas L.Pro Member
    Flipper/Rehabber · Pittsburgh · Member since 2018 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    3y

    @Elizabeth Kinde

    with interest rates where they are, if you just buy any old property on the MLS that is in decent shape and rent it out, it's probably not going to cash flow at all. so... it's just not a great time for cash flow right now on vanilla LTRs.

    if you haven't already, check out some of the recent episodes of the Sunday BP podcast, where David Greene answers listener questions.  he's been really good on this point lately.  

    so like the others i wouldn't recommend that anyone, regardless of the source of their funds, sink most or all of what they have into a single rental that's break even or negative.  it just doesn't make a lot of sense, unfortunately.

    hope this helps and happy to answer any additional questions

  • Michael BaumPro Member
    Olympia, WA · Member since 2016 · 8k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    3y

    Hey @Elizabeth Kinde, first off, you should qualify for Medicare health insurance if you have SSDI.

    Are you looking to move into your own place as well or just stay with family?

    You could look at an FHA multi family loan. Lower down on up to a 4 plex. Live in one and rent the others.

    It isn't easy being disabled. It is even harder prepping for full retirement when you can't actually save for it. I think you can have a savings account though. Plus you can't take advantage of IRA's and the like, but you can invest directly in mutual funds, stocks etc. It isn't as protected, but it can be done.

    Plus you can do something like a treasure bond rollover strategy. Pretty high rates on the 13 week Tbills. Roll over and get about 5.35%. Not great, but better than most.

    If anything, don't just go blow the back pay on something like a trip. Save it for a rainy day. 

  • Dayton, OH · Member since 2023 · 3 posts · 3 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Michael Baum:

    Hey @Elizabeth Kinde, first off, you should qualify for Medicare health insurance if you have SSDI.

    Are you looking to move into your own place as well or just stay with family?

    You could look at an FHA multi family loan. Lower down on up to a 4 plex. Live in one and rent the others.

    It isn't easy being disabled. It is even harder prepping for full retirement when you can't actually save for it. I think you can have a savings account though. Plus you can't take advantage of IRA's and the like, but you can invest directly in mutual funds, stocks etc. It isn't as protected, but it can be done.

    Plus you can do something like a treasure bond rollover strategy. Pretty high rates on the 13 week Tbills. Roll over and get about 5.35%. Not great, but better than most.

    If anything, don't just go blow the back pay on something like a trip. Save it for a rainy day. 

    I need day to day assistance, so living on my own in a 4 plex isn't feasible, unfortunately.

    Anyone who is awarded SSDI has to wait a qualifying period of 24 months before they have access to Medicare, unfortunately. If I had that insurance to fall back onto, I wouldn't be worried about saving up. But until then I need to make sure I continue qualifying for Medicaid. And that means come next October I need to have <$2k in the bank and <$7k in total assets that aren't a car and a mortgage. Medicaid does, unfortunately, count savings accounts. You might be thinking of the ABLE savings account, but you need to have been determined to be disabled before your 26th birthday to qualify for that.  I'm "allowed" to put money into mutual funds and stocks, but Medicaid still looks at those as assets for determination.  It would be exactly the same as keeping the money in savings or in cash from a determination standpoint.

    So I really can't save it. I need to figure out the best way to spend before my next Medicaid review.

    ----

    I want to thank everyone for your thoughtful replies!  It's at least heartening to know there isn't an easy solution that I've missed in my research.  

  • Real Estate Broker · New York, NY · Member since 2020 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    3y

    Hey @Elizabeth Kinde - firstly, don't be deterred by some of the more blunt responses. They're valid responses, but doesn't mean they couldn't have landed softer. 

    It seems you may be aware that you're not going to qualify for traditional loan options without a steady income coming in. 

    I skimmed through your long post. If you'd still like exposure to real estate then I recommend finding a way to wholesale (i.e. flip contracts) in your market. 

    I've never worked in your market, however I've heard on more than one occasion that your neck of the woods seems to have opportunity for contract flips. 

    Good luck to you! 

  • Michael BaumPro Member
    Olympia, WA · Member since 2016 · 8k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    3y

    Roger that @Elizabeth Kinde. I didn't get that you have had a recent decision and you are right about Medicaid as well. I should have read closer. Sorry about that.

    So I did a search on Medicaid disqualifiers and decision. Here is all the info for OH from the Council on Aging.

    https://www.medicaidplanningassistance.org/medicaid-eligibil...

    Most of what I looked up prohibits you from owning any real estate other than you primary home like you said. Extra cars, stocks & bonds, etc. Here is a list I found about general Medicaid info.

    • Checking and Savings Accounts – Any checking or savings account with your name or your spouse’s name count as an asset. Therefore, having a high amount of funds in those accounts could disqualify you. This includes long-term savings accounts or investments like CDs.
    • Stocks and Bonds – Any investment accounts you have, including bonds, stocks, or funds, count toward your eligibility. These are considered assets that you can withdraw and pay for medical expenses and long-term care. Therefore, the state will assume you have enough funds to pay for your care.
    • Real Estate Other Than Your Primary Residence – Your primary residence does not count. But if you own secondary property such as a rental home, vacation property, or even a co-owned property like a timeshare, these count.
    • Extra Cars – Your primary vehicle will not count, but any additional cars and recreational vehicles do count as assets.
    • Life Insurance – The cash value of a life insurance policy also counts. If the amount exceeds $1,500, then any excess is considered an asset to your estate and will be considered in your application.
    • Cash – While you can possess some cash, too much may disqualify you. For example, if you have $50,000 in a checking account, it would most likely disqualify you unless you could prove those funds were dedicated to something specific.

    Bottom line Elizabeth is that in order for you to qualify for Medicaid, you need to be indigent for the most part. A primary home, a car etc is allowed but that is about it.

    I don't think you will be able to invest at all if you need Medicad to survive.

    Here is the Council on Agings info on how gifting your cash to the family member affects Medicaid eligibility.

    https://www.medicaidplanningassistance.org/gift-tax-exemptio...

    I hate to be such a Debbie Downer, but there are reasons why there are so many restrictions.

  • Member since 2022 · 22 posts · 15 votes
    3y

    Sorry you are having to navigate this when you’ve already had to adapt to so much.


    There’s something called a Special Needs Trust you could look into: https://www.forbes.com/advisor/legal/estate-law/special-need...

  • Investor · Cleveland, TN · Member since 2016 · 280 posts · 187 votes
    3y

    @Elizabeth Kinde I would google/bing/whatever "medicaid planning assistance Dayton, OH". A medicaid planner can work with you to ensure that you will qualify next year. I would think there is an option for either a free consult or a needs based service, but this is not something I'm familiar with.

    As @Michael Baum said, he knows more about this than most here, pretty much any investment at this point is going to disqualify you from medicaid. So really your question isn't about investments as much as it is about qualifying for medicaid after you receive back pay. The only "investment" option would be purchasing a house/duplex/etc, but you would have to owner occupy it for it to be excluded as an asset. FYI, you only have to owner occupy it for a year. I don't know your situation, so I don't know if a year is even a possibility. (BTW, there's likely a hardship loophole where you intended to live in it for a year, but after attempting to live alone you realized it wasn't feasible. I'm not advocating you buy without the intent to live in it, but if you were to buy, move in, and then realize this is absolutely not going to work, there are options. Again, not advising you to commit mortgage fraud, just know that you aren't completely locked in if you want to attempt owner occupying.)

    Another option is to do home repairs/updates that add value to your life while lowering your cash on hand. There are particulars to this that I don't know, please check with a professional beforehand, especially as you do not own the home you live in. 

    BTW, do a search for Pace Morby on this website before subscribing to his, or any other's, services. Most of the guru's are about enriching themselves first and foremost, whether or not their followers make any money is of secondary, or no, concern.

  • Member since 2023 · 10 posts · 2 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Elizabeth Kinde:

    Firstly want to thank this community and forum, I've found myself being directed back to it a number of times as I've been digging around the internet for information.  I realize my situation is a complex one, and I'll try to be as thorough as possible. 

    I was recently awarded SSDI, and with that about $19k in backpay.  I know that's not a lot, all things considered, but it's very likely the largest lump sum of money I'm ever going to get.  My SSDI is my only income, and my disability prevents me from working to supplement it.  I live with family so my monthly expenses are minimal and leave me with about $500 a month that I comfortably could put aside for a potential investment (and/or mortgage payment).  I would like to invest it, but my options are extremely limited.  Medicaid is need based and takes most financial assets into consideration when it determines whether you qualify.  (I would be able to collect a net cash flow of aprx. $5k from a rental without getting kicked out of Medicaid.  In two years I'll qualify for Medicare and this whole thing will be moot.)

    I can't invest in things like CDs, IRAs, ETFs/Mutual funds, or any type of savings account.  Real estate is one of the few things that I can invest in that won't knock me out of qualifying for Medicaid when I have to renew next year.  So, unfortunately, if I wanted to invest this money, I'd need to do it before October '24.  If I had unlimited time to figure out what to do with it, I wouldn't be in such a pickle.  

    I don't have any wealthy investor friends or family I can approach for cash.  I don't own my own home that I can put up as collateral.  So far as I can tell, pretty much all traditional mortgages, as well as down payment assistance programs and low income grants, would both disqualify me based on the debt/income that a mortgage would put me at, and necessitate my occupying any purchased real estate as my primary residence.  This would defeat the purpose of my purchase in the first place.  

    DSCR loans are going to need a minimum loan amount of $100k and a down payment of 20-30%. So the minimum I'd need for a down payment is around $25-40k on a $130k house. Even if I pushed my monthly savings up to $600 a month, it would still take me 10 months to save up the $6k to hit the very bottom of that threshold. And even then, it's highly unlikely that I would secure a mortgage and close on a house before my next income review.

    I live in Dayton, OH and roughly an hour from both Cincinnati and Columbus.  I could get a very nice little income property for $130k in that bubble of cities.  If I had time.  

    I'm running out of ideas for how to twist this to make it work, but I doubt I've been 100% exhaustive in my research.  If anyone has any insights or suggestions, I would be extremely grateful.  Or would it simply be better to put the idea of investing out of mind, and just go on a nice vacation lol.

    Thank you all so much for your time.

    The only thing about the Medicaid restrictions that don’t seem to make
    sense to me = 

    * Medicaid will allow you to own and live in a primary residence / property, however they will NOT allow you to have savings <$7K to stay qualified?

    Homes 🏡 take upkeep, and upkeep usually takes extra expense & costs over time = Not just a home “insurance policy” either?! 

    God Bless & Good Luck 
  • Michael BaumPro Member
    Olympia, WA · Member since 2016 · 8k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    2y

    Well @Monique Rene Coates, it does make sense.

    The system is rife with fraud. People who are scamming the system and it is a problem for all of us.

    There are other ways to help pay for expenses, like SSI supplemental. Helps pay for expenses.

    I am actually trying to help my brother-in-law navigate all of this right now. It is very difficult and assets are a real problem. Every state is different when it comes to the look back time. Some are 3 years some are much more.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.