Are out of state property managers worth it?

[Patrick F.]

Hi all, I'm coming close to buying my first rental as an out of state STR. I have been in contact with a local property manager who charges 18% to manage the listings on their accounts (Airbnb, Vrbo, etc), take care of cleanings, help with stockings, set the prices, and really just let me collect a paycheck every month. Given that this is my first rental (and the nerves are there), this seems like a nice convenience for peace of mind.

However I was crunching some numbers and it looks like self managing could almost double my cash flow. I’m a little worried about finding cleaners and handling stocking of household items. I also worry that having a new Airbnb/Vrbo account could lead to review-volatility as opposed to using a PM’s established account.

Anyone have advice on the above? Any tips on finding out of state cleaners & stockers? (especially in South Bend!) Any suggestions for PM softwares like Guesty, etc? Thank you!