Your thoughts when 1 applicant has great credit but the other....

[Sacha LaCoss]

I have a set of applicants that are a couple moving in together.

Applicant 1 has a 773 credit score and can easily meet the 3x rent income on his own. Librarian for the city 

Applicant 2 has a 561 credit score but has obviously been improving as she has 100% on time payments, no evictions or judgments ect.. and can almost meet the 3x rent income on her own.  Graphic Designer 

both have very little debt 

Both have clean criminal ect...And have been in their current separate rentals for over 2 years each.  If I can verify that the second applicant has been current on rent ect and get a good landlord reference what do you guys think on renting to this couple?