Lease renewal but possible property damage

[Charlotte Chew]

Hi all, I have a rental property and tenants want to renew their lease at the end of the month. I've heard there may be some holes in drywall and a door being pulled off hinges because of the guy has some anger issues. The neighbor said the couple argues loudly and the police have been called a few times. They have been paying rent on time. I told the tenants that I will be doing an inspection upon lease renewal. Any suggestions on how I should handle the situation if I do have damaged dry wall or doors? Do I still renew their lease?