Rental Insurance Claim Affecting Primary Residence Insurance?

[Ken Musial]

I was just shopping around for primary residence home owners insurance and am running into a few issues with major carriers not wanting to insure my property.  It turns out that a water leak claim from a rental condo is tied to my social security number and thus major insurers are shying away from me even though the two properties are not related.  Has anyone ever run into this before? If so, are there ways around it?

Thanks,

Ken