First rental rehab! Bathroom tile or pre-fab?

[Josh Brosius]

I’m rehabbing my first rental and I’m running into some issues that have varied opinions when I research it. I have a super small bathroom on my first floor I’m going to fix up while I live in it. It’s only a 6 by 5 bathroom with barely and space to move but I think it work. The bathtub/shower has a window on the one wall opposite of the shower head but is frosted so you can’t see in. Because of this I would have to cut the pre-fab shower wall to the window. My question is should I tile or do the pre-fab. Tile looks better but it’s a rental and would need the tenant to help maintain which I don’t want to rely on. I do agree it would look a lot nicer though.