Thinking Renting My House Out

Thinking Renting My House Out

Pasadena, TX · Member since 2010 · 10 posts · 1 vote

I am thinking of renting my house out, and buying another closer to my job since real estate prices are a lot lower there than where I live now. I am just hoping to get some advice from some more experienced investors. My current mortgage is right at $1200 a month, and my house should rent at the lowest for 1400, most likely $1450. I really don't expect much positive cash flow from this. These are the main reasons for considering this:

1.A long term investment of the tennant slowly paying off my mortgage.

2. Gaining interest on my house that is appraised at 145,000, over a number of years if it only averaged 3% a year, in 24 years would value at 290,000

3. The tax benefits, I am taxed at around 30%, and I could see about a minimum of $15000 in write offs between interest, taxes, depreciation, maintenance, etc.

4. Eventually the rent should keep going up, and the mortgage should stay the same maybe reduce, when the PMI is down is down to 20%

Those are my reasons, I am just looking for someone with more experience to say if it looks like a good idea. I am also wondering how much I need to have in store of cash to cover what rent may not. I am also considering having a property management company take it as most cost 10% percent of the rent, wich is also tax deductible, so about $100 a month not to be on call 24/7 for the tennant seems like it might not be to bad. I appreciate any help you can give me.

Thanks,
Clint

1Reply
29 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Mercer Island, WA · Member since 2008 · 22k+ posts · 14k+ votes
16y

You're not going to come close to breaking even. If your PITI is $1200, I'm guessing your P&I part of this is $900 given Texas' high real estate taxes (used to live there). You need at least $1800 in rent to break even. At $1400/month you're in the hole $400 a month, or $4800 a year as a rental.

The $1400 might include P&I, taxes, and homeowner insurance. It doesn't include landlord insurance (buy this or don't bother, homeowners won't cover the tenants burning the place to the ground), vacancy, utilities when its vacanct, maintenance, make ready, eviction costs, tenant damage, etc.

Now, with just the one property you might get lucky and have a tenant in there all the time and have no problems. Or, you might get unlucky and have the tenant from hell who costs you $10K in addition to your PITI payment. If you're not prepared for the, just sell the place and move on.

Being able to use passive losses from a losing rental to offset ordinary income is a dodgy propositiion. If your AGI is under $100K, you can do it. If your AGI is over $150k, you're out of luck.

See this reply in the discussion

8 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Brian LevredgePro Member
    Investor · Chattanooga, TN · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 903 votes
    16y

    If you have the cash to lose every month and don't mind doing so, go for it. I don't know if your $1200 for mortgage included the taxes and insurance as well but those need to be accounted for. Then you have maintenance, vacancies, lease ups (management) , capital expenses, and so on. Most of those are deductible at the end of the year but you have to pay for them when they occur. Rents, like property values, don't always increase. In many markets they are dropping right now.

    What is the market like where your home is. Are properties renting, and for how much? How long does it take? These are also factors you need to consider. As it stands, you are going to be losing money every month because your expenses will exceed the income and that is when the place is rented.

  • Pasadena, TX · Member since 2010 · 10 posts · 1 vote
    16y

    Well, just like anybody else, I dont care to lose cash every month, but if it was minimal, and worked out to make more in the long run, then I might be able to part with some. The 1200 includes everything, mortgage, insurance, taxes, etc.... I am hoping that it could come close to breaking even for the year, and I would see about 5,000 in tax benefits for the year. Do you think its worth it in the long run, or better to stay where I am? Thanks for the help.

    Clint

  • Rental Property Investor · Mercer Island, WA · Member since 2008 · 22k+ posts · 14k+ votes
    16y

    You're not going to come close to breaking even. If your PITI is $1200, I'm guessing your P&I part of this is $900 given Texas' high real estate taxes (used to live there). You need at least $1800 in rent to break even. At $1400/month you're in the hole $400 a month, or $4800 a year as a rental.

    The $1400 might include P&I, taxes, and homeowner insurance. It doesn't include landlord insurance (buy this or don't bother, homeowners won't cover the tenants burning the place to the ground), vacancy, utilities when its vacanct, maintenance, make ready, eviction costs, tenant damage, etc.

    Now, with just the one property you might get lucky and have a tenant in there all the time and have no problems. Or, you might get unlucky and have the tenant from hell who costs you $10K in addition to your PITI payment. If you're not prepared for the, just sell the place and move on.

    Being able to use passive losses from a losing rental to offset ordinary income is a dodgy propositiion. If your AGI is under $100K, you can do it. If your AGI is over $150k, you're out of luck.

  • Pasadena, TX · Member since 2010 · 10 posts · 1 vote
    16y

    Thanks for the info both Jon and Brian, sounds like I will hold for the time being, maybe once I have it paid down a little more and the rent for my area goes up some I will look into it again. I am wondering just out of curiosity now, how someone would rent a place out and make a profit from it. It seems like it would almost take buying a house for $100,000 and renting it out for $1600. I have thought about doing this for a while, just wondering what it would take, since it seems like it would take a lot. Thanks.

    Clint

  • Brian LevredgePro Member
    Investor · Chattanooga, TN · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 903 votes
    16y
    Originally posted by Clint Nelson:
    Thanks for the info both Jon and Brian, sounds like I will hold for the time being, maybe once I have it paid down a little more and the rent for my area goes up some I will look into it again. I am wondering just out of curiosity now, how someone would rent a place out and make a profit from it. It seems like it would almost take buying a house for $100,000 and renting it out for $1600. I have thought about doing this for a while, just wondering what it would take, since it seems like it would take a lot. Thanks.

    Clint


    If you search "50% rule" in the forums you will find lots of great info. Over time and spread over multiple properties, your expenses will equal about 50% of the gross rent. This includes vacancy, management, maintenance, taxes, capital expenses, etc. Your remaining NOI is for debt service and profit. That is why you want to buy as low as possible.

    In your earlier scenario using the higher rent, a one month vacancy is equal to a $133 per month loss. Management is going to run you $160 (10%) and you will also pay half a month's rent in leasing fees which is another $66 per month. Right out of the gate, you have another $359 on top of your $1200 which leaves you $41 per month. Maintenance, cleaning, gardener (don't expect your tenant to take care of it) will put you in the hole another couple hundred when averaged out. Then you have small costs like advertising and big ones like evictions which means legal fees + vacancy since the tenant isn't paying.

  • Lexington, KY · Member since 2010 · 315 posts · 133 votes
    16y

    Couple months old post, but I would like to add - If you are renting a SFR and carrying a mortgage of $1200 and getting rent of say $1500 -that's great. But if you purchase another home with a decent size payment you have to keep in mind the fact that one of the downfalls of SFR renting is that if one tenant moves out your occupancy goes immediately from 100% to 0% and you are now carrying two mortgages which will cost you a combined $2,500+ (depending on the second house you buy). And that is not to mention the extra insurance, maintenance, and taxes.

    Bottomline is, make sure you keep it rented, even if you have to rent a bit below market to keep it occupied at all times - unless carrying two mortgages is of no concern to you.

  • San Antonio, TX · Member since 2009 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    16y

    It really depends on you and what your situation is. Many folks who end up renting their own home do so because they've had to move either due to a job transfer, change of situation, etc. And, then they may become accidental landlords. If you do plan to rent your home out, it definitely is a learning experience. It will teach you about becoming a landlord - the types of things that come up such as filling homes, monthly and yearly maintenance, etc. I would say it really depends you and what your goals are. It's always best to have a time frame and exit strategy on any potential investment. If you have a 9-5 job and feel you may not have the time to manage the property, bringing in a good property management company is a good route to take. Hope that helps!

  • Real Estate Investor · the villages, FL · Member since 2008 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    16y

    I think original poster is gone, but I'll offer a contrarian view. I'd keep the residence and rent it. I find the 50% rule is bunk on newer properties. Also, the poster is in 30% tax bracket. Here are benefits of keeping and buying another.
    1. Selling in down market is bad
    2. Texas is going up sooner than later
    3. Tenant is paying off your loan on res
    4. All the interest on new home is tax deductible and at 30% bracket, it may save you enough to offset any neg from repairs on first home etc
    5.2 homes appreciating instead of one

    Yes, you may have a vacancy, repairs etc. If you're in the 30% tax bracket, my guess is you can afford the bumps in the road. Rich

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.