Tenant Asking for discount on utilities/rent need help!

Tenant Asking for discount on utilities/rent need help!

Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2016 · 45 posts · 4 votes

Hi BP Community,

My tenant/neighbor let me know of an issue related to water seeping from my top floor condo unit into the unit below approximately 1 month ago.

I contacted contractor #1 and I was told that they would be at my property on Thursday, he simply didn't show or even contact me, later found out was not licensed. I called back and he simply didn't pick up whatsoever.

Contacted contractor #2 and this time I was given a quote of $1000 to repair this issue with my bathroom, also found out contractor #2 was not licensed which led me to terminate  I contacted contractor #3 to get a quote as well and this quote came out to $6300 due to the bathroom in my condo not being built to Sandy Springs, GA code. 

I contacted Statefarm to see if they would be willing to cover the cost of these unexpected repairs. They told me that they would be unable to cover the repair costs. I said ok and now I'm continuing to work with Contractor #3 so that I can continue knowing that what work that is being done to the property will be done to code and is done correctly by a licensed contractor. 

Now my question is, my tenant is now demanding that I give her some sort of concession/discount on her rent due to her not being able to use the shower in that condo. There are a total of two showers in the condominium. Those of you who are landlords what actions have you taken which have led to a positive outcome? I don't want to give the discount/concession because I'm bleeding on one side and this would allow me to recoup funds that were sitting in another account for the repairs. I'm a bit confused and feel a bit blindsided by the tenant. If someone would be willing to talk over the phone later today anytime after 4pm EST so that I can talk this through I'd really appreciate it.

-Danial Qureshi 

0Reply
22 views

Most Popular Reply

kansas City, MO · Member since 2014 · 31 posts · 10 votes
9y

Is the tenant demanding or asking for a discount?

If they are demanding for a discount I wouldn't give it to them because you don't owe them anything unless it states it in your lease. But if they are asking nicely and are good tenants who take care of the property I would want to keep them and take a bit off the rent. Taking a little off rent for a month is much cheaper then them leaving and having a vacancy for a couple months.

I have one tenant who is the nicest and I'm happy to give a discount to if she deserves it but another tenant I charge them for everything because they are a pain to deal with and actually wouldn't mind if they left. 

If you were in their shoes renting the property, would you want a discount for all your troubles? 

Its a grey area and up to you ultimately if you want to provide a discount and the amount you are willing to discount. 

See this reply in the discussion

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • kansas City, MO · Member since 2014 · 31 posts · 10 votes
    9y

    Is the tenant demanding or asking for a discount?

    If they are demanding for a discount I wouldn't give it to them because you don't owe them anything unless it states it in your lease. But if they are asking nicely and are good tenants who take care of the property I would want to keep them and take a bit off the rent. Taking a little off rent for a month is much cheaper then them leaving and having a vacancy for a couple months.

    I have one tenant who is the nicest and I'm happy to give a discount to if she deserves it but another tenant I charge them for everything because they are a pain to deal with and actually wouldn't mind if they left. 

    If you were in their shoes renting the property, would you want a discount for all your troubles? 

    Its a grey area and up to you ultimately if you want to provide a discount and the amount you are willing to discount. 

  • Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    Ask her what she thinks is fair.. she's living with a contractor in her house and now I bathroom is out of commission. What would you expect.

    I'd say depending on rent amount 20% discount...

  • Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2016 · 45 posts · 4 votes
    9y

    @Joshua Ibarra thank you for the prompt reply you make a good point. I was trying to look at it from their perspective, maybe I'm just overwhelmed because I wasn't expecting this to cost me $6300 plus lost potential rent. Overall they are good tenants so I'll give them a discount I guess then what would be a reasonable discount if rents are $1500? $100, $250, $500? Would you offer the lowest then go up in increments to minimize the amount of lost rent and come to something reasonable?

  • Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2016 · 45 posts · 4 votes
    9y

    @Deanna McCormick thank you for the quick response to be honest I don't know what to expect I've never been in a similar position. 

  • Mike CumbieBusiness Member
    REALTOR® · Brockport, NY · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    9y

    @Danial Qureshi

    Loss of use is generally covered in a renters insurance policy and she should be directed that way. As a landlord though 1 month is way too long for an issue involving water leakage to sit dormant and I would guess that helped to cause her frustration. I will not claim to know the prices in Atlanta but I can have a shower, toilet and vanity all replaced and new flooring put down for less than $6300. I have a hard time believing there is a leak in a bathroom that to stop from leaking will cost that much. Most plumbers I know can at least get the leak stopped that day in some fashion. Sure there may be a hole in the drywall left or a drain you can't use until it gets completed, but a month and $6300 with water still leaking into her place?

    I would expect to hear more in regards to mold next month especially if you pay. So I guess my advice would be to have the leak stopped now, not tomorrow, not next week and fix the issues in her bathroom so it is back up to standard. Then go to making your upstairs bathroom useable again.

    Good Luck!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.