Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
General Landlording & Rental Properties
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

Updated over 8 years ago on . Most recent reply

User Stats

34
Posts
14
Votes
Isaak Brown
  • Investor
  • Oakland, CA
14
Votes |
34
Posts

Flooring: Worth the extra labor cost for porcelain?

Isaak Brown
  • Investor
  • Oakland, CA
Posted

I am renovating a 4plex, for rental units. Tearing out carpet, and based on the great threads here, was planning to porcelain. My floor guy said the extra labor cost to lay down porcelain isn't worth it, and recommended vinyl plank. He said plank takes 1 day, porcelain could take 3. 

Thoughts/experience between the two?

Isaak

Most Popular Reply

User Stats

9,828
Posts
15,794
Votes
JD Martin
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
15,794
Votes |
9,828
Posts
JD Martin
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
ModeratorReplied

Porcelain looks great but I would not use it in a kitchen. I won't even use it in my own kitchen anymore. I am on the 2nd (porcelain) tile floor in my own kitchen over 20 years, and even with 3/4 subfloor, cement board, high strength thinset with flex agent, there are still about 6 or 7 hairline cracked tiles from where something heavy has been dropped on them - errant can, hot pot, milk jar, etc. Bathroom, that's a different story, and I love using tile in bathroom.

Either way, the new vinyl is fantastic for rentals. I doubt you make the extra money back on a 4 plex by going with tile. I have been using the vinyl planks or the large Allure adhesive-edge vinyl 3 foot tiles lately, and the tenants actually seem to prefer them as they are simple to keep clean and hard to destroy. 

business profile image
Skyline Properties

User Stats

1,047
Posts
596
Votes
Travis Sperr
  • Lender
  • Denver, CO
596
Votes |
1,047
Posts
Travis Sperr
  • Lender
  • Denver, CO
Replied

I am still using vinyl in rental properties - the product has come a long way in both looks and durability. Typically less than 1/4 the price of tile. Vinyl plank is pretty cool for future repairs, but is still pricey in my experience. Of course factors like, price, typical tenant, etc plays a role.

User Stats

1,639
Posts
955
Votes
Chris T.
  • Investor
  • Downers Grove, IL
955
Votes |
1,639
Posts
Chris T.
  • Investor
  • Downers Grove, IL
Replied

Porcelain can crack, and fixing it is could be more difficult/costly than vinyl. 

Hospitable logo
Hospitable
|
Sponsored
Hospitable.com’s software makes short-term rental management easy Hospitable's STR software delivers a higher return without extra hassle. Get a 14-day free trial.

User Stats

2,030
Posts
3,308
Votes
Anthony Gayden
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Omaha, NE
3,308
Votes |
2,030
Posts
Anthony Gayden
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Omaha, NE
Replied

I have porcelain tile in every single unit I own. I replaced the carpet in one unit with it, even though it was costly. 

  • Anthony Gayden
  • Podcast Guest on Show #21
  • User Stats

    1,512
    Posts
    1,436
    Votes
    Gail K.
    • Augusta, GA
    1,436
    Votes |
    1,512
    Posts
    Gail K.
    • Augusta, GA
    Replied

    We love using the Allure Vinyl planking in our rental properties. Quick, easy to put down, wears well.  Generally if we're not using the color we've purchased during the Black Friday sale we'll go with the color what runs around $1.79 a square foot.

      Wait for the Black Friday sale at Home Depot; they typically offer it at the store and online at 99 cent a square foot.  Investors often purchase thousands of feet of the stuff during these sales.


    Gail

    Account Closed
    • Greensboro, NC
    20
    Votes |
    45
    Posts
    Account Closed
    • Greensboro, NC
    Replied

    I would go with tile instead of vinyl only if it was needed to be competitive with similar apartment/plex units in the market. Vinyl should be easier and cheaper to maintain as well.

    User Stats

    9,828
    Posts
    15,794
    Votes
    JD Martin
    • Rock Star Extraordinaire
    • Northeast, TN
    15,794
    Votes |
    9,828
    Posts
    JD Martin
    • Rock Star Extraordinaire
    • Northeast, TN
    ModeratorReplied

    Porcelain looks great but I would not use it in a kitchen. I won't even use it in my own kitchen anymore. I am on the 2nd (porcelain) tile floor in my own kitchen over 20 years, and even with 3/4 subfloor, cement board, high strength thinset with flex agent, there are still about 6 or 7 hairline cracked tiles from where something heavy has been dropped on them - errant can, hot pot, milk jar, etc. Bathroom, that's a different story, and I love using tile in bathroom.

    Either way, the new vinyl is fantastic for rentals. I doubt you make the extra money back on a 4 plex by going with tile. I have been using the vinyl planks or the large Allure adhesive-edge vinyl 3 foot tiles lately, and the tenants actually seem to prefer them as they are simple to keep clean and hard to destroy. 

    business profile image
    Skyline Properties