Help with insuring multiple rentals

[Justin R.]

Hello BP friends. I am a rather new invester, but apparently hit a threshold. I currently have USAA insurance (whom I like very much) and they insure my primary residence, autos, umbrella, and 12 rentals (in 4 different states).  Unfortunately, they will not insure any more rental properties. I have called the next highest rated national insurance company (Amica) but they will only insure 4 properties. I have called a few local brokers, but they are only licensed to insure homes in the few states to do so.

I was hopeing to utilize one insurance company for all of my needs, is this possible to do with a good insurance company and a high level of service?

Thank you for all your input

Justin