Legally picking applicants

[Joe Aagaard]

I just listed my property and am getting about 1-2 replies a day and have set up three viewings so far.  Thing is it sounds like some tenants might be preferable over others (example one is looking for 2 year lease and sounded qualified).  

Can I take  a handful of applications over the week and cherry pick?  I know the protected class thing but do I have to take them in order or can I tell people I will decide in say 5-10 business days and choose the best?

What is your processes?

[Jeff Rabinowitz]

You most certainly do NOT have to take the first application you receive even if they are qualified. You may accept the best qualified applicant.  You can determine the selection criteria as long as it does not include the protected classes. For instance, I will never rent to a cop nor a lawyer no matter how qualified they may appear on paper. Neither of these are protected classes.