To furnish, or not to furnish

Most Popular Reply

Realtor · Sebastian, FL · Member since 2018 · 53 posts · 30 votes
3y

Hey Carlo, that strongly depends on your strategy and market. Obviously if its a STR or MTR you will need to furnish. I'm assuming you're doing a LTR here, so what does your market say considering you're in NYC? Is this property in a high rise building? Something where it would be a pain for tenants to constantly move in and out of with furniture and deal with freight elevators and scheduling times with building, etc.? If so, offering furnished could probably be ideal for that situation...but again, it depends...

See this reply in the discussion

19 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Realtor · Sebastian, FL · Member since 2018 · 53 posts · 30 votes
    3y

    Hey Carlo, that strongly depends on your strategy and market. Obviously if its a STR or MTR you will need to furnish. I'm assuming you're doing a LTR here, so what does your market say considering you're in NYC? Is this property in a high rise building? Something where it would be a pain for tenants to constantly move in and out of with furniture and deal with freight elevators and scheduling times with building, etc.? If so, offering furnished could probably be ideal for that situation...but again, it depends...

  • New to Real Estate · NY · Member since 2023 · 127 posts · 58 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Eric Jubeck:

    Hey Carlo, that strongly depends on your strategy and market. Obviously if its a STR or MTR you will need to furnish. I'm assuming you're doing a LTR here, so what does your market say considering you're in NYC? Is this property in a high rise building? Something where it would be a pain for tenants to constantly move in and out of with furniture and deal with freight elevators and scheduling times with building, etc.? If so, offering furnished could probably be ideal for that situation...but again, it depends...


    Hi Eric, Thanks for chiming in. I'm not familiar with the acronyms STR, MTR, LTR? Could you let me know what they spell out? Sorry absolute newbie here.

  • New to Real Estate · NY · Member since 2023 · 127 posts · 58 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Eric Jubeck:

    Hey Carlo, that strongly depends on your strategy and market. Obviously if its a STR or MTR you will need to furnish. I'm assuming you're doing a LTR here, so what does your market say considering you're in NYC? Is this property in a high rise building? Something where it would be a pain for tenants to constantly move in and out of with furniture and deal with freight elevators and scheduling times with building, etc.? If so, offering furnished could probably be ideal for that situation...but again, it depends...


     Eric,


    I did quick google search and it gave me the answer. My follow up question would be what time frames qualify as MTR vs LTR? Thank you in advance!

  • Realtor · Sebastian, FL · Member since 2018 · 53 posts · 30 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Carlo D.:
    Quote from @Eric Jubeck:

    Hey Carlo, that strongly depends on your strategy and market. Obviously if its a STR or MTR you will need to furnish. I'm assuming you're doing a LTR here, so what does your market say considering you're in NYC? Is this property in a high rise building? Something where it would be a pain for tenants to constantly move in and out of with furniture and deal with freight elevators and scheduling times with building, etc.? If so, offering furnished could probably be ideal for that situation...but again, it depends...


     Eric,


    I did quick google search and it gave me the answer. My follow up question would be what time frames qualify as MTR vs LTR? Thank you in advance!


     Hey Carlo, the MTR would typically be anything for minimum 30 days or multi-months, like here in FL for example we do a lot of seasonal rentals of a few months at a time. Some even do furnished MTR just over 6 months to avoid tourist tax as well. Whereas LTR is your typical long term rental with an annual lease term in place. What will be your strategy here? And what type of property is it?

  • Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2021 · 9k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    3y

    Furnishing it will require a lot more capital. To justify it, you need to see what you can rent it for furnished. Otherwise, keep it un furnished. 

  • New to Real Estate · NY · Member since 2023 · 127 posts · 58 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Eric Jubeck:
    Quote from @Carlo D.:
    Quote from @Eric Jubeck:

    Hey Carlo, that strongly depends on your strategy and market. Obviously if its a STR or MTR you will need to furnish. I'm assuming you're doing a LTR here, so what does your market say considering you're in NYC? Is this property in a high rise building? Something where it would be a pain for tenants to constantly move in and out of with furniture and deal with freight elevators and scheduling times with building, etc.? If so, offering furnished could probably be ideal for that situation...but again, it depends...


     Eric,


    I did quick google search and it gave me the answer. My follow up question would be what time frames qualify as MTR vs LTR? Thank you in advance!


     Hey Carlo, the MTR would typically be anything for minimum 30 days or multi-months, like here in FL for example we do a lot of seasonal rentals of a few months at a time. Some even do furnished MTR just over 6 months to avoid tourist tax as well. Whereas LTR is your typical long term rental with an annual lease term in place. What will be your strategy here? And what type of property is it?


     Hey Eric, thank you again for being so responsive. My strategy is to just basically hold it and rent it out. It's a coop and I purchased it cash.  

    With these high interest rates, the math just wasn't working. But I also believe that now is the time to invest in something.  My personal thesis (which is not new and is actually quite a common view) is that with interest rates basically doubling, but real estate prices not going down, now is the time to buy.  The fed lowering the rates in the future (no matter how long that may be) or even a change in their language during fed meetings that hint at a reduction can cause a surge in demand thus increasing property prices even more. 

    So my long term plan is to just hold it and cash flow from it. I never intend to sell it. I intend to leave it to my kids when I'm gone. It's held in an LLC which is owned by my family trust. If and when rates go down, I can just access the equity then.

    Sorry if that was much more detail than you asked for. But I wanted to give you a better picture in hopes that you'd have some insight that I might have missed. 

    Thank you again.

  • Contractor · Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2010 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3y

    As Eric said it just depends on your market.

    In my market I know a few areas that do really well furnished. Houses that will rent for $2,500 unfinished will go for $3,500-$4,000 furnished.

    Renting unfurnished means less money to spend to get the unit up and running. Also if you go unfurnished you'll never need to worry about your dining chairs falling apart, couch getting stained, coffee mugs breaking, etc.

    I'd talk with a local realtor who knows the rental market really well and get their feedback.

  • New to Real Estate · NY · Member since 2023 · 127 posts · 58 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Eliott Elias:

    Furnishing it will require a lot more capital. To justify it, you need to see what you can rent it for furnished. Otherwise, keep it un furnished. 


     Thank you Elliot, the basic math is I will cash flow at least $1200/month from it. I paid cash for it so no mortgage.  Given those specifics, would you furnish it if you were in my shoes? I am only looking to furnish it with middle of the road furnishings... Nothing expensive or dirt cheap that I would need to replace them every year. Thank you.

  • New to Real Estate · NY · Member since 2023 · 127 posts · 58 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Scott E.:

    As Eric said it just depends on your market.

    In my market I know a few areas that do really well furnished. Houses that will rent for $2,500 unfinished will go for $3,500-$4,000 furnished.

    Renting unfurnished means less money to spend to get the unit up and running. Also if you go unfurnished you'll never need to worry about your dining chairs falling apart, couch getting stained, coffee mugs breaking, etc.

    I'd talk with a local realtor who knows the rental market really well and get their feedback.


     Thank you so much Scott. I appreciate your chiming in. 

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    3y

    @Carlo D.  I just want to bring up one other factor, if the unit is small say a studio or smaller 1 bed you might consider furnishing if the area is right for furnished rental.  You can right size the furniture and decrease some of the wear and tear of moving things in and out. You tend to get traveling health workers or people relocating.   What does the co-op allow as the shortest lease?

  • New to Real Estate · NY · Member since 2023 · 127 posts · 58 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Colleen F.:

    @Carlo D.  I just want to bring up one other factor, if the unit is small say a studio or smaller 1 bed you might consider furnishing if the area is right for furnished rental.  You can right size the furniture and decrease some of the wear and tear of moving things in and out. You tend to get traveling health workers or people relocating.   What does the co-op allow as the shortest lease?

     @Colleen F. It is a studio. Not sure about your other questions. I'd have to ask. But I myself would be looking for Long term renters. I'm even open to doing 2 or 3 year leases. 

  • Bonnie LowPro Member
    Lender · Asheville, NC · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    3y

    Before you do anything, research the regulations in New York City. My understanding is that they either have banned or are going to ban short term rentals. Given the highly regulatory environment there, I'd want to research it no matter what I planned to do with it, be that long term, midterm or short term.

  • New to Real Estate · NY · Member since 2023 · 127 posts · 58 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Bonnie Low:

    Before you do anything, research the regulations in New York City. My understanding is that they either have banned or are going to ban short term rentals. Given the highly regulatory environment there, I'd want to research it no matter what I planned to do with it, be that long term, midterm or short term.

     Thank you @Bonnie Low. Yes you are correct. Airbnb is all but illegal here now. (I believe unless its more than 30 days. Not sure) Fortunately that was never a consideration of mine. I was just wondering if longer than the standard one year lease had any specific advantages or disadvantages to it. Thank you again. 

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    3y

    @Carlo D.  Its a difficult call in your situation talk to a relator or someone who knows the area.  I would consider how difficult it is to get furniture in the building and unit and if there are any unique aspects to the place that make furniture difficult to fit. What do other studios in the area advertise? Even with LTR if you expect issues with furniture size, elevator scheduling, or everyone else does furnished consider furnishing. (note that NYC I believe even has a room tax for less than 90 days) so your LTR strategy avoids that. Not a fan of multiyear leases, they lock you in but the tenant will leave when they want. if you do them build in rent increases. Good luck.

  • New to Real Estate · NY · Member since 2023 · 127 posts · 58 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Colleen F.:

    @Carlo D.  Its a difficult call in your situation talk to a relator or someone who knows the area.  I would consider how difficult it is to get furniture in the building and unit and if there are any unique aspects to the place that make furniture difficult to fit. What do other studios in the area advertise? Even with LTR if you expect issues with furniture size, elevator scheduling, or everyone else does furnished consider furnishing. (note that NYC I believe even has a room tax for less than 90 days) so your LTR strategy avoids that. Not a fan of multiyear leases, they lock you in but the tenant will leave when they want. if you do them build in rent increases. Good luck.

     Thank you very much @Colleen F.

  • Lender · United States · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 499 votes
    3y

    Depends on a few things, like will the monthly increase be worth the costs of the furniture?

    Another thing to factor in: financing. If you ever plan to refinance with a DSCR lender, they typically go off the market rent in the area of unfurnished properties. So lets say the property rents for $2k unfurnished, but $2,500 furnished, the lender will view it as $2k, which, for a DSCR lender, can reduce your LTV.

  • New to Real Estate · NY · Member since 2023 · 127 posts · 58 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Timothy Hero:

    Depends on a few things, like will the monthly increase be worth the costs of the furniture?

    Another thing to factor in: financing. If you ever plan to refinance with a DSCR lender, they typically go off the market rent in the area of unfurnished properties. So lets say the property rents for $2k unfurnished, but $2,500 furnished, the lender will view it as $2k, which, for a DSCR lender, can reduce your LTV.


     Thank you.

  • Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
    3y

    STR = short-term rental. Anything you rent for 30 days or less is a STR. These are fully furnished with all utilities included. Most often used for vacation homes, but sometimes rented as an MTR for people new to the area, between homes, etc.

    MTR = medium-term rental. This is a dangerous term that I wish would die an ugly death. It describes anything rented for longer than 30 days but is typically furnished and all-inclusive like a short-term rental.

    LTR = long-term rental. Anything rented longer than 30 days is legally considered LTR. When renting an LTR, it is recommended you screen the applicants, collect a security deposit, have a strong, written lease agreement, etc. 

    Many people make the mistake of treating MTR like a STR instead of LTR. If you rent for more than 30 days, you should have a written lease, security deposit, and do everything as if it were a LTR.

    I do not furnish LTR. Most people staying for a year or more will want to have their own furnishings. People staying for shorter periods of time typically want a furnished rental.

    The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
  • New to Real Estate · NY · Member since 2023 · 127 posts · 58 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Nathan Gesner:

    STR = short-term rental. Anything you rent for 30 days or less is a STR. These are fully furnished with all utilities included. Most often used for vacation homes, but sometimes rented as an MTR for people new to the area, between homes, etc.

    MTR = medium-term rental. This is a dangerous term that I wish would die an ugly death. It describes anything rented for longer than 30 days but is typically furnished and all-inclusive like a short-term rental.

    LTR = long-term rental. Anything rented longer than 30 days is legally considered LTR. When renting an LTR, it is recommended you screen the applicants, collect a security deposit, have a strong, written lease agreement, etc. 

    Many people make the mistake of treating MTR like a STR instead of LTR. If you rent for more than 30 days, you should have a written lease, security deposit, and do everything as if it were a LTR.

    I do not furnish LTR. Most people staying for a year or more will want to have their own furnishings. People staying for shorter periods of time typically want a furnished rental.

     Thank you @Nathan Gesner

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.