Umbrella insurance company recommendation

[Tina Paduck]

We recently had to change from Amica to Geico because we purchased too many properties to qualify for Amica. We had an umbrella policy with Amica for $1mil that cost us ~$250 a year. Geico recommends we increase the liability to $3mil, which we agree, but quoted us ~$1,800. Since we moved all our policies to Geico, Amica will not give us a standalone umbrella insurance.

Can you recommend a company that will give us a more reason rate for the umbrella? We have properties in Illinois and Massachusetts, if that matters.

TIA!