garage vs 1 more room

[Gerald King]

My house is comparable to the ones in the neighborhood. We all have 2 bedrooms and 2 baths plus 1 car garage (attached).

Should I do away with the garage and turn it into another bedroom/master retreat and then add a detached storage in the back yard for the lawn mower etc. Will the house appraise for more money without the garage and the additional bedroom? Is it better to have more rooms and no garage or always a plus to keep the garage?

What is the best bet...let me know your thoughts please.

Gerald