Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here

Join Over 3 Million Real Estate Investors

Create a free BiggerPockets account to comment, participate, and connect with over 3 million real estate investors.
Use your real name
By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.
The community here is like my own little personal real estate army that I can depend upon to help me through ANY problems I come across.
General Real Estate Investing
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

Updated 9 days ago on . Most recent reply

User Stats

3
Posts
1
Votes
Bryce Cover
1
Votes |
3
Posts

Analyzing the Impact of Selling vs. Renting My Property

Bryce Cover
Posted

I'm in my early 30s, married, with one child and another on the way. We're planning to move three hours away soon.

Currently, we own one Class A rental property that generates about $500/month in cash flow. Additionally, we have a decent amount invested in retirement accounts, which we plan to continue building over time.

As part of the move, we’ll be purchasing a larger home. While I love the idea of eventually owning a paid-off primary residence, I’m debating whether it’s smarter to sell our current house and use the equity as a down payment on the new home or to keep it as a rental. I wonder if the disciplined, long-term play is better than having the cash now. However, I’m unsure about the utility of having two paid-off rentals 25 years from now. Is selling now a mistake? I’d appreciate your perspectives.

Here are the details about our current home:

  • 3/2 Class A property in a middle-America town with historically ~1% annual appreciation.
  • Purchased in 2020 for $200,000 at a 3% 30-year fixed rate.
  • Remaining mortgage: $150,000.
  • Estimated value: $270,000 (based on recent sales).
  • After selling costs: Likely $100,000 in net proceeds.
  • Rental potential: $2,000–$2,300/month.
  • PITI: $1,200/month ($700 mortgage + ~$500 insurance/taxes).
  • Maintenance/CapEx/Vacancy (20%): ~$400/month.

If kept as a rental:

  • Net cash flow (self-managed): ~$500/month or ~$300/month with property management.
  • Low appreciation potential but ~$400/month in principal paydown.

Considerations:

  1. What’s the additional overhead of managing a second rental property remotely (3 hours away)?
  2. The house has a new roof, but HVAC and water heater replacement might be needed in the next few years.

Also, mortgage rates are currently around 7%. Selling would allow me to put the $100,000 equity toward the new primary home, potentially avoiding a larger loan.

What would you do in this situation? Is it smarter to hold onto the house and keep renting it out, or sell now and roll the equity into the new home?

Most Popular Reply

User Stats

1,644
Posts
831
Votes
Mohammed Rahman
  • Real Estate Broker
  • New York, NY
831
Votes |
1,644
Posts
Mohammed Rahman
  • Real Estate Broker
  • New York, NY
Replied

Hi @Bryce Cover,

First, congratulations on your growing family and your successful real estate investment so far! You've done well with your Class A rental, generating $500/mo in cash flow, this adds up over time. Consider managing remotely you'll have to be willing to travel 3 hours when needed or find a way to handle it virtually. Maintenance and potential repairs will also require a long-term financial plan and setting aside a contingency fund for such expenses.

The steady cash flow, appreciation over time, and tax benefits can make a meaningful difference to your wealth in the long term, especially with the principal paydown on the mortgage.

However, if managing the property from a distance feels too burdensome, or if you’d prefer the certainty and flexibility that comes with having less debt (especially given the high mortgage rates), selling and using the $100,000 in equity to reduce your loan for your next home may be the smarter move. It could give you peace of mind as you focus on your family and move to your new home, without the additional stress of managing a second property from afar.

Best of luck with your decision! You’re in a great spot either way! Let me know if you need further insights.

Loading replies...