Why are listings priced higher today than they sold for in 2004-201212 in Ohio?

[Schuyler Smith]

Looking at listings from $275 - $315K in Northeast Ohio (canton, green) and I see a lot of sellers paid $25-$35K less than what they are listing them for.

Some of these have been on the market for months. Are the sellers dreaming? I would think these homes built from year 2000-2013 would depreciate or be at the same value today.

Any advice or expert opinions would be greatly appreciated!