What are the top 5 zip codes in Columbus, OH for residential?

Question

What are the top 5 zip codes in Columbus, OH with the highest rental cash flow, lowest turnover/vacancies, lowest crime rates, great schools, and great employers for residential 2-4 unit single-family home neighborhoods? Class A neighborhoods.

Remington Lyman · Answer

I think 43215, 43201, 43202, 43212, and 43214 are solid A class zip codes in Columbus, Ohio

Patrick Drury · Answer

@William Hinsche
Cash flow is non-existent in A-class neighborhoods. If you are looking for cash flow you need to be looking at more C locations because the lower price of entry paired with market rents allows for higher cash flow. For example, Hilltop, Franklinton, Linden, and Whitehall/ Eastmoor are great places to look.

Scott Allen · Answer

@William Hinsche  I personally enjoy looking for multi-family in 43212, 43201, 43202, 43215, and 43235 as these are are areas that I would live in myself to buy and owner-occupy. Taxes in these zip codes might be higher but they're great long term holds with steady appreciation. Lower turnover/vacancies is a result of a desired area to live and time of the year when leasing a property.

If you're looking for good cashflow you should look into 43211, 43204, 43213, 43227, and 43222.Taxes in these areas will be lower and you'll have much more room for cashflow but you'll want to make sure you have a solid property manager to help get and collect market rents, find long term tenants, and keep the property maintained.

Feel free to reach out if you have any other questions.

Remington Lyman · Answer

A lot of new investors do flips in Linden, Hilltop, and Whitehall in Columbus, Ohio

Rehaan Khan · Answer

Which areas do you recommend to look for flip projects? I’m not familiar with Ohio but looking to do my next project there. I’m interested in buying lower priced properties & selling them for a quick turn around time. Happy to work with good realtors as well.

Vince Iacobelli · Answer

Class A neighborhoods and "highest rental cash flow" dont really go hand in hand in columbus Oh, and most likely many other markets in the country. Generally if you look for properties in locations with stronger macro statistics you will see that rents and price points tend to diverge from each other. Meaning your price points will be much higher than the rents for the areas.

If you are looking for great areas to cashflow and very reasonable ARV's that allow for value add investment strategies, I can't reccomend whitehall enough. Additionally the south side of columbus (southern orchards, merion village, olde towne east, franklin park) all have great macro stats, and density due to its proximity to the urban core in columbus. That being said there are many other areas that can work for investing so long as the numbers work.

Zip Codes:

Whitehall: 43227-43213

SouthSide: 43206-43205-43203

Click here for a link to the market data report for whitehall.

If you want any further questions answered, or want to compare some areas you are looking at shoot me a message. I can pull some other reports for different areas and show you the difference in the stats.

Jay Thomas · Answer

While I can't definitively say which are the absolute top 5 zip codes in Columbus, I can help you narrow your search for Class A neighborhoods that offer a good balance of rental cash flow, low vacancy rates, safety, and strong school systems.Some promising areas to consider based on general market research include New Albany (43064), known for excellent schools, safety, and strong rental demand, although cash flow might be lower due to higher property values. Dublin (43017) offers similar benefits, but affordability could be a concern. Upper Arlington (43212) is an established Class A neighborhood with good schools and potentially stable rental income. Galena (43026) is a growing area with newer developments, offering good rental income and lower vacancy rates. Westerville (43081) is a family-friendly area with good schools and potentially steady rental demand, but it's essential to analyze vacancy rates and rental income expectations.

Alfath Ahmed · Answer

I would look into B- to C locations in Columbus like Hilltop, Linden, Whitehall, and Eastmoor will have the best cashflow.

If you want all of the above that you mentioned. It will unfortunately not be attainable in the Columbus market.

Samuel Diouf · Answer

You can find the low priced flips in zip codes like 43211, 43213, 43223, and 43219. Columbus is a city that is growing at a rapid rate so it's a great city to do buy and holds as well.

What are the top 5 zip codes in Columbus, OH for residential?

Most Popular Reply