To separate utilities, or not to separate utilities...

To separate utilities, or not to separate utilities...

Joey NakayamaPro Member
Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 129 posts · 68 votes

My situation:

I own a triplex in Chicago, live on the first floor and rent out the upper two.

Cooking gas is separated for each unit, but a single hot water boiler heats the entire building. This last (brutal) winter, whenever the outside temp dipped below 10 degrees the boiler ran constantly and couldn't quite keep up. My gas bill was around $650 during the worst months.

Also, the radiators on the third floor don't work as well as those on the other floors. My third floor tenant is moving out at the end of the month, so now would be my opportunity to install a separate heating system for that unit.

My questions:

Are there simple ways to make my current system effective? (For instance, flush the current pipes to clear out any partial blockages)

What options are worth looking into for a separate system? (Electric baseboard heat, forced air system, hydroponic system?)

Can anyone recommend a great contractor in the Chicago area to speak with about this?

What would you do? Any thoughts from folks with experience in this area would be much appreciated.

0Reply
85 views

Most Popular Reply

Mechanicsburg, PA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
12y

I would NOT put in electric baseboard, it is the cheapest to install but very expensive to operate especially in older buildings with old windows and little insulation.

I would recommend gas, especially since you already have separate metered gas for each unit. Probably gas hot water boiler and separate gas hot water heater for each unit. You could save a little by leaving your unit on the old system and replace that later.

A more costly alternative would gas hot air heat requiring new ducts, but would make central air possible.

We've done both alternatives many times.

See this reply in the discussion

11 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Mechanicsburg, PA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    12y

    I would NOT put in electric baseboard, it is the cheapest to install but very expensive to operate especially in older buildings with old windows and little insulation.

    I would recommend gas, especially since you already have separate metered gas for each unit. Probably gas hot water boiler and separate gas hot water heater for each unit. You could save a little by leaving your unit on the old system and replace that later.

    A more costly alternative would gas hot air heat requiring new ducts, but would make central air possible.

    We've done both alternatives many times.

  • Investor · Vancouver, WA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    12y

    I like natural gas forced air systems the best. Economical and circulating air reduces moisture in the unit and thus less potential for mold.

    If you do electric, avoid baseboard heaters as they take up too much linear feet on the wall and tenants are more likely to block them or drop things into them... creating a fire hazard. Electric forced air is fine, if the electricity costs in your area are not too high. I also like electric fan heaters that install in the wall made by Cadet, especially their new top of the line one (just under $200).

    Choose Energy Star appliances when possible. Check with your local utility companies for special deals they might be offering through incentive programs.

    Some utility companies will do a free home energy audit. If there are weatherizing subsidies offered to low income folks in your area, see if any of your tenants would qualify. You may be able to get a house insulated this way for free or at a significantly lower price and that will save you on heating costs. I looked into it once and learned it doesn't matter who owns the building as long as the person residing there qualifies.

  • Rental Property Investor · State College, PA · Member since 2013 · 287 posts · 99 votes
    12y

    If you're looking for a good contractor w/ experience in lowering energy bills, look for a BPI or RESNET certified contractor. Those guys look for ways to cut energy bills.

    You did not specify the type of boiler you have (steam or hot water), but since you say 'flush the pipes', I'm assuming hot water. I would NOT flush the pipes in the boiler (I install boilers). This can lead to additional corrosion w/in the pipes, possibly leading to premature failure of the heat exchanger, which is not inexpensive to fix as I just fixed one on one of my properties.

    Assuming you're on gas, you could (imo: should) install a condensing gas boiler. Your costs should drop by at least 20%, if not more.

    If your property is steam heat, my ideas above are out the window.

    - If you have two pipe steam (one pipe coming in one side of the radiator, another pipe leaving the other side of the radiator), you may be able to convert your system to a boiler, which I would highly recommend.

    - If it's one pipe steam (only one pipe entering the radiator), you've got no cheap options (sorry)

  • Chicago, IL · Member since 2014 · 710 posts · 200 votes
    12y

    @Joey Nakayama

    Sounds like you have a circulator pump issue or the boiler is undersized.

    Don't do electric base board it's very expensive monthly

    I would recommend Unique Indoor Comfort for any boiler issues .

    You could separate the system by doing Forced Air and put the furnace in the attic if your not in a bldg with a flat roof. Not cheap when you have radiators to disconnect and run ducts. I would focus on repairing the current system or putting in a new HIgh Efficiency boiler

  • Joey NakayamaPro Member
    OP
    Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 129 posts · 68 votes
    12y

    Thanks for the detailed advice, everyone! I will look into the boiler options mentioned as well as the relative cost difference for installing a forced air system. It would be nice to have the possibility of installing central air, but the prospect of installing ducts, disconnecting and removing radiators and repairing the floors/walls where the radiators were sounds expensive.

  • Calumet City, IL · Member since 2014 · 312 posts · 49 votes
    12y

    I kinda just went though this. My tenants pay their whole gas bill for heat and cooking. However two of the 4 boilers needed to be replaced right before the harsh winter. If I were you, you could do a few things.

    1. Consider the cost of more energy efficient replacement windows. This will save you money if you continue to keep the Building on one boiler.

    2. How old is the boiler you have now? If you replace it with a much newer one, it should be more efficient thus less expensive to run.

    3. I like the idea of separate heat where the tenant pays their own bills. If you can do forced air gas heat that would probably be best.

    4. You say the third floor does not heat as well as the others. Find out why, could be circulator pump not strong enough or something else.

    5. Finally what about hot water. You could also look into having that separate for each tenant.

  • Real Estate Investor · Audubon, PA · Member since 2009 · 13k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    12y

    The most likely blockages in radiators on the upper floors with an old boiler are air pockets! Bleeding the system is required to let that air escape and be replaced with water. Some of those older systems require the water source to be opened to allow for filling of the system. Then you go to the radiators on each level with a cup and radiator key, and starting with the lowest floor open the radiator bleed valve with the key while holding the cup below the valve to catch water; close the bleed valve when you get water out. Move up one floor at a time and repeat at each radiator. This is something you should do in the autumn to get improved heat flow to upper levels.

  • Brie SchmidtBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    12y

    @Joey Nakayama when did you last bleed the radiators? That would be my first move. Second would be to have a boiler inspection and consider replacing it. Our Portage Park 3 flat is about 3600 sq feet and our gas bill for the year is $1,500 to run the boiler and water heaters. We got a ballpark quote to convert it to a central system and it was 10k per unit not including the AC or Furnace. Usually, any problem is fixed by bleeding. We had never had rad heat and once we learned to bleed our lives were a million times better

  • Joey NakayamaPro Member
    OP
    Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 129 posts · 68 votes
    12y

    Thanks @Jarrett Harris @Steve Babiak @Brie Schmidt I have bled the radiators in the past and that does help. One of the third floor radiators, despite bleeding, never gets warm.

    I had a new pump installed recently, but the boiler itself is pretty old — 1987 I think. I'm calling HVAC guys to check out the system and suggest options.

  • Real Estate Investor · Audubon, PA · Member since 2009 · 13k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    12y

    For the radiator that does not get warm, does it have a control valve that is stuck so circulation does not reach it? Most radiators get hooked up in a series or daisy chain, but maybe this one is connected differently?

  • Joey NakayamaPro Member
    OP
    Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 129 posts · 68 votes
    12y

    @Steve Babiak The strange part is that I can bleed that radiator, and water comes out steadily but never quite gets warm.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.