Low end rentals bring low end tennants?

[Ryan Lepage]

Hey guys I'm looking at purchasing my first rental property. My dilemma is that I cant decide between buying a lower end property in a not great neighbourhood, or spend much more in a better area?

Option 1 

Purchase price 80-120k

potential rental income 800-1200/mo

Option 2 

Purchase price 200-280k

potential rental income 1200-1500/mo

My issues aren't  so much with the numbers per say but with the potential of bad tenants filling in the bad areas. I'm having a hard time trying to come up with a value for turnover and damages. Any help would be greatly appreciated.