Background: We are just starting out with real estate investing and bought our first investment property last October (a short-term rental that can be easily transitioned into a long-term rental if needed, but it's doing great as a STR so far). Our goal is to buy and hold. The BRRR strategy is one we'd really like to utilize (did this with the house we live in, actually, and it REALLY paid off), but we aren't in a position for a major rehab at this particular time in our lives (cosmetic or minor fixes though - sign us up!)
Question: do we use the cash we have for 2 more single-family homes that we can rent out and gain equity in over time, or sit on the money and wait for a structurally-sound multifamily property (4-plex?) to come along (they are hardly EVER available)?
The answer is in the question. What are your goals? If you are looking to utilize the cash immediately, then move forward with the SFR. If you are dying to get into a 4 unit, either look somewhere else, or hold out. Jumping into a 4 plex is always great, but if you are creating equity at the same rate, does it matter? Go back to your goals, review what is most important, and make a decision. If you don't have a plan, then make one. If a 4 plex came along, you can always sell a house and 1031 the investment in (provided you aren't living in it). Hope that helps.
If you have the capital for 2 SFR's I would invest instead in 2 Duplex's. Duplex's are much less of a unicorn than a 4-Plex and you would have 4 units vs 2 SFR's. Your market is a large factor in how these investments would pan out, good luck!