Advice for buying first multi-family property in the current market

Advice for buying first multi-family property in the current market

Member since 2023 · 2 posts · 2 votes

Hello, all! I heard about BP through Brandon Turner's The Book on Rental Property Investing and hope I might be able to get a little bit of advice or even just some words of encouragement.

I've taken a real interest in rental property investing and have felt for a long time that I want to start out with buying a multi-family property and house hacking. This seems to be the best way to go based on my own goals. I'm still very new to the concept but have definitely learned a lot through reading books and browsing other topics here. However, I guess I'm a little discouraged at the moment, given the state of the market and overall economy right now. It's difficult enough learning but in these unprecedented times, there seems to be even more to be aware of.

Traditionally, it seems that the best way to go for a first-time homebuyer is an FHA and a 3.5% down payment. With this in mind, I feel that I already have more than enough to cover a down payment and closing costs on a starter's quality duplex or triplex in a middle-class area in my city (I live in Buffalo). I'm not expecting anything luxurious but a property good enough for a beginning investor to call their first. Regardless of city, have any of you or anyone you know purchased their first investment property in a similar situation recently? Some questions I have are whether an FHA is even a possibility given the current market or is it going to be really difficult for a first-time investor to get one? Or would a conventional actually be better by putting down, say, 20%, instead for less of a payment? I understand other factors may affect this but just want to get a general idea on your thoughts or strategies.

I recently saw a triplex on my street go up for sale with an ask of $189k. The first day it was available was Tuesday. The Zillow listing, however, had no interior photos. For the price and location, I was guessing it would go fast, although without interior photos, you never know. When I walked outside Tuesday around 5:00 PM, there were cars flooding the street with people checking it out. I was thinking of checking it out before seeing all of the competition but once I saw that, I questioned whether I'd even stand a chance as a first-time investor over many potential buyers who could be paying cash or have better financing options for a property like this. Granted, there may have been a slew of people checking it out since there were no interior photos, but it looked like there was a lot of interest from others with likely much more leverage than me at this point. It's going to be tough for anyone to get into a bidding war, although I think it's an even worse idea for someone just starting out.


The last concern I have is the current interest rates. Has anyone that has recently made a purchase been able to still get some cash flow even with the high rates? Ideally, I'd find myself in a really good spot if I were able to pay the mortgage with the tenant's rent and just have to worry about utilities, but is anyone struggling to even do that with how things are right now? Just wondering if you think this is still a possibility or if it's even plausible to get a little cash flow in these trying times as a beginner.


I would really like to buy sooner than later, as waiting may end up being worse in a year or two. I know no one can predict the future and we can really only go off of trends and historical data, so I'm going to avoid asking the ever-popular question "Should I buy now or wait?" No one can give a sure answer to that. I guess I'm more so asking whether there's hope for aspiring investors interested in buying a first multi-family property in the current market or if it's really impractical at this time. At least I believe location is on my side, as Buffalo seems much more affordable than other big cities. I'm a believer that there's always a way, so would you say all hope isn't lost for someone like me at this time?

1Reply
94 views

Most Popular Reply

Member since 2023 · 40 posts · 34 votes
3y

Hi @Joseph Shilen,

I invest in Western New York too. I would not worry too much about the interest rates because you can always refinance later. The old saying is "It's not when to invest in the market; it's about how long you've been in the market".

The current market with higher interest rates is actually a good place for beginner investors because there is less competition. Once interest rates begin to drop, more people will flood the market with the already limited supply, which will increase the price further.

I agree with @Devon Huff. Do not stand in the sidelines. Yes, today's interest rates are intimidating, but we also must factor in property's appreciation. Home prices will not be the same in a couple of years, especially if rates decrease.

If you have more questions, feel free to shoot me a DM. Keep up the good work, Joe!

Best,

Tommy Nguyen

See this reply in the discussion

6 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Agent · Tipp City, OH · Member since 2018 · 65 posts · 35 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Joseph Shilen:

    Hello, all! I heard about BP through Brandon Turner's The Book on Rental Property Investing and hope I might be able to get a little bit of advice or even just some words of encouragement.

    I've taken a real interest in rental property investing and have felt for a long time that I want to start out with buying a multi-family property and house hacking. This seems to be the best way to go based on my own goals. I'm still very new to the concept but have definitely learned a lot through reading books and browsing other topics here. However, I guess I'm a little discouraged at the moment, given the state of the market and overall economy right now. It's difficult enough learning but in these unprecedented times, there seems to be even more to be aware of.

    Traditionally, it seems that the best way to go for a first-time homebuyer is an FHA and a 3.5% down payment. With this in mind, I feel that I already have more than enough to cover a down payment and closing costs on a starter's quality duplex or triplex in a middle-class area in my city (I live in Buffalo). I'm not expecting anything luxurious but a property good enough for a beginning investor to call their first. Regardless of city, have any of you or anyone you know purchased their first investment property in a similar situation recently? Some questions I have are whether an FHA is even a possibility given the current market or is it going to be really difficult for a first-time investor to get one? Or would a conventional actually be better by putting down, say, 20%, instead for less of a payment? I understand other factors may affect this but just want to get a general idea on your thoughts or strategies.

    I recently saw a triplex on my street go up for sale with an ask of $189k. The first day it was available was Tuesday. The Zillow listing, however, had no interior photos. For the price and location, I was guessing it would go fast, although without interior photos, you never know. When I walked outside Tuesday around 5:00 PM, there were cars flooding the street with people checking it out. I was thinking of checking it out before seeing all of the competition but once I saw that, I questioned whether I'd even stand a chance as a first-time investor over many potential buyers who could be paying cash or have better financing options for a property like this. Granted, there may have been a slew of people checking it out since there were no interior photos, but it looked like there was a lot of interest from others with likely much more leverage than me at this point. It's going to be tough for anyone to get into a bidding war, although I think it's an even worse idea for someone just starting out.


    The last concern I have is the current interest rates. Has anyone that has recently made a purchase been able to still get some cash flow even with the high rates? Ideally, I'd find myself in a really good spot if I were able to pay the mortgage with the tenant's rent and just have to worry about utilities, but is anyone struggling to even do that with how things are right now? Just wondering if you think this is still a possibility or if it's even plausible to get a little cash flow in these trying times as a beginner.


    I would really like to buy sooner than later, as waiting may end up being worse in a year or two. I know no one can predict the future and we can really only go off of trends and historical data, so I'm going to avoid asking the ever-popular question "Should I buy now or wait?" No one can give a sure answer to that. I guess I'm more so asking whether there's hope for aspiring investors interested in buying a first multi-family property in the current market or if it's really impractical at this time. At least I believe location is on my side, as Buffalo seems much more affordable than other big cities. I'm a believer that there's always a way, so would you say all hope isn't lost for someone like me at this time?

    I believe as long as the numbers make sense on a particular deal, it’s a buy. If you have the capital ready to go to cover: down payment, closing cost, any necessary repairs once you buy the property, plus cash in reserves for unexpected costs, there’s no reason to wait for prices to come down (they may never).

     That being said, don’t just buy the first property you see. Learn to properly run the numbers. Make sure the numbers make sense and align with your goals. I think a Househack is a great way to get your feet wet. I would consider it a lot less risky then other strategies.

    Moving forward you should start building up your team in your area. Find a good lender and get pre-approved. Then, find a good agent that can help guide you through the process. In the meantime practice running your numbers (Biggerpockets has some nice calculators on the site you can use).

  • Real Estate Consultant · Buffalo, NY · Member since 2018 · 49 posts · 24 votes
    3y

    @Joseph Shilen our local investors meeting is Wednesday June 14, 6-9p at the Dome in Tonawanda.  Come join us.

  • Alecia LovelessPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    3y

    @Joseph Shilen Keep researching properties and running numbers. Become a BP Pro member where you can use their rental property analysis tool calculator as much as you want any to to analyze tons of deals. It takes a while to become good at this and learn to spot the great deals.

    In your market there should still be some good deals. You’re in a large market with pro sports teams, colleges, and tons of industry. It’ll likely come down to finding your neighborhoods and looking at deals there every day to stay on top of things.

    Get your pre approval so you’ve got your money lined up and then when you find something be ready to move fast. You can’t afford to wait! And you can’t be afraid to go over list price a little to be competitive.

    If you find a good agent maybe they can get you an inside to some pocket listings where you get first dibs on things, or meet an investor at a meetup who will sell something to you off market.

    Best of luck!

  • Investor · Buffalo, NY · Member since 2023 · 11 posts · 0 votes
    3y

    "When in doubt, do something." You are never better off on the sidelines.

    As with  pretty much any investment, it's  impossible to time it perfectly, so you are better off just getting in the game. And house hacking is such a no-brainer that you basically can't lose. (I say "basically" can't lose because you certainly COULD find an awful deal if you try hard enough.)

    Don't bother asking anyone here about loans. It's not like you won't get decent advice, but in the end there's no escaping the need to make a few dozen phone calls to bank after bank after bank after bank after bank. There's no shortcut to this. You just gotta call around, see what you qualify for, and do the math to see if it makes sense.

    Another thing to consider is that you don't necessarily need to be buying a duplex or triplex. You could do a bigger house and rent out the rooms individually. Or, if you DO end up getting a duplex, don't feel the need to keep a full apartment to yourself. Rent out one apartment, and then rent out the extra room or two in the one you live in. With minimal effort, you should be able to live for free.

    Regarding interest rates, they only seem high right now because they've been so low for so long. There's no reason you shouldn't be able to make a deal work at these rates.

    Hope that helps. If you have more specific questions, feel free to fire them off.

  • Member since 2023 · 40 posts · 34 votes
    3y

    Hi @Joseph Shilen,

    I invest in Western New York too. I would not worry too much about the interest rates because you can always refinance later. The old saying is "It's not when to invest in the market; it's about how long you've been in the market".

    The current market with higher interest rates is actually a good place for beginner investors because there is less competition. Once interest rates begin to drop, more people will flood the market with the already limited supply, which will increase the price further.

    I agree with @Devon Huff. Do not stand in the sidelines. Yes, today's interest rates are intimidating, but we also must factor in property's appreciation. Home prices will not be the same in a couple of years, especially if rates decrease.

    If you have more questions, feel free to shoot me a DM. Keep up the good work, Joe!

    Best,

    Tommy Nguyen

  • Alex HilemanPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2023 · 225 posts · 147 votes
    3y

    Hi @Joseph Shilen, don't be afraid to go to showings! You have just as much right to be there as any other investor.

    Alecia is right, agents can sometimes get you into a house a few days before it hits the market. Agents and wholesalers also have access to off-market deals. Take advantage of this free database of inventory. The more properties you see in your market, the better you can judge the after repair value.

    Interest rates were over 18% in the 80s. They were historically low during COVID and I wouldn't wait around for those low rates to come back.

    I would start with something in your area, connect with local agents and contractors, attend local investor meet ups, and keep running your numbers until you find a deal that you can afford and checks your boxes.

    Happy investing!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.