It makes sense to turn over the renter at this point (we wouldn't be able to rehab with them in there) and it didn't even occur to me to bring in someone new as a month-to-month while listing it.

If your talking about a Chicago property, your lease is subject to LTO, that more or less nullifies both common sense and common real real estate laws outside 606.

And I have been super fortunate but I don't make a TON of money or we'd be buying in LA ;) ) I've listened to SO many BP podcasts and read dozens of books on this topic...it seems a lot of good investors buy property they haven't seen as long as the market is healthy and the numbers make sense.

This is crazy and doesn't make sense to me that we qualify for this refi on every aspect but can get held up for $1200 that i can't just pay now?

I personally wouldn't buy any rental without at least a 15% return so it makes sense that his offer would be higher than mine.

My sense of humor is sometimes, shall we say, interpreted incorrectly.Second, I did a search and your name came up frequently (hence my comment).

What is your sensing of the market ?

Search RE online - get a sense for sale and rental values on your own.

That make sense, and what I anticipated.

You can say "well that's common sense".