What type of terms are you looking for ? 

You need enough time to earn healthy returns, but not so much that your kids graduate before the sale.Considering market cycles, five years is a modest stint in which to invest, make improvements, allow appreciation, and exit before it’s time to remodel again.A five-year projected hold provides a buffer between the estimated sale and the typical seven- to ten-year commercial loan term.

I would reach out to the short-term shop and speak with one of their OBX agents.

@Alexandra Joy  From your answers it seems like this might be a furnished medium term rental and if it is the first tenant you have had in it you may be seeing some of kinks in the property, your process and you may also have a demanding tenant. 

In order to give you the best advice, I really need to know what your long term goals are.

Rented one out long term and AirBnB-ed the other.

I have a long term rental (SFR) which I converted to an Airbnb in October 2019.  

Since you used your property as a Short-Term Rental (STR) for two years, it might qualify.

Currently, we have a portfolio of 35 long-term rental properties, and we're managing these with the help of Yardi Breeze.

If property is not redeemed I get a deed in the mail.REally like this play for assets that are inexpensive.. and your paying cash.. risk is minimal to nill and as long as your play is simply rent and keep very long term.. its a genius move.. most folks are so worried that you have little to no competition..  !!!!