We have been through 2 months of appraisals with 2 different appraisers both of which have refused to appraise our property because they claim that there is a lack of comparable properties in the area. 

Your profit depends on the type of home, area and competition.  

Maybe you listened to your coach who made notes of games or team competitions. 

Lack of W2, lump of cash, and some experience flipping?

If one or more people are sleeping in the room then the problem is most-likely cause by the vapor the person(s) are breating.As mentioned in several posts, my company deals with your type of problem and most-often the problem is the result of the people breathing vapors when they sleep and lack of good air movement and ventilation in the room.

We have been through 2 months of appraisals with 2 different appraisers both of which have refused to appraise our property because they claim that there is a lack of comparable properties in the area.

CONSLower revenue potential vs B & BStill need to get the B & B license (and still need to provide "breakfast" even coffee & donuts)STR biz model would mean much hight taxes vs B & B business (from what I understand)HUGE Airbnb competition - area is highly desirable but oversaturatedPROSGreat revenue for an under $500k total investmentQuicker ramp up to produce revenueCan become passive much sooner than a B & B OPTION 3.

Condensation in the panel probably is due to a lack of insulation behind the box (ie, the insulation is removed to make room for the box between the studs.)

@Joshua TanWe have access to a Landlord insurance program that includes 2500 deductible, 1 million liability, replacement cost, loss of rents, and water back up that is very competitive in price.

On the VA loan topic - great in theory, but Milwaukee has become a very competitive market.