@Chandan SinghMaybe move them back in, take 30% of the profit from their "business" ?

Our acquisitions reps are simply skilled negotiators (we use John Martinez's) sales methodologies.

Read Kiyosaki's book "Rich Dad, Poor Dad" which will help you understand why real estate is a fine investment.Put on your "Sunday best" (dress up) and simply go to the Open.

If you invested in the property with the intent  to increase profit get them all to market asap.    

You always want competition from a number of fish; not the only fish in the pond on the day you need a contract.This is not a state with high wage earners like NY/ CA/ DC, so even one additional line item can affect profit.

Every LLC then needs to file a tax return and should be showing profit and loss and balance sheet separately.

Simply call them up (or going in may be better) and tell them what you're hoping to do (buy a 2-4 unit property, live in one unit, rent the others out).

And if it is, can my personal LLC withdraw 50% of the profits (rent, gains at sale) legally? 

If you have a RE license/real estate is your full time profession, you pay reg taxes on profits from selling real estate- I buy and hold for at least a year and sell some flips periodically so that is not my main business and I pay a much lower tax rate as mine are capital gains

Are properties that are profitable grouped together forming the micro-markets you are looking for?